Vibe

Alternatives to every community and membership platform

People search for an alternative when something has started to hurt: a fee that grew with them, a feature that was never built, a rule change, or a feeling that the members belong to the platform and not to them. This hub covers sixteen platforms creators leave, says what each one is actually good at, and points to the detailed page for each. The numbers are from the platforms' own pricing pages; where a platform publishes none, the hub says so.

The short answer

Short answer: The right alternative depends on why you are leaving. If the reason is the fee, move to a flat plan; if it is a missing tool, move to the platform built around that tool; if it is ownership, move somewhere that exports your members' emails on demand. Vibe is a flat-plan community for a craft that takes 0% of what supporters pay and exports every member in one click.

16platforms creators most often search for an alternative to
12of them with a fee verified on their own pricing page
1 clickto export every member's email from a Vibe, any day

What to look for before you pick the next one

Most creators switch platforms once and then stay for years, so it is worth choosing on the things that matter in year three rather than the things that look good in week one.

  • The fee model, and the month it starts to hurt. A share grows with you; a plan does not; a plan plus a share does both. Work it out on your own numbers, not the headline rate.
  • Who the merchant is. If the platform charges the card, the platform holds your money and pays you on its schedule. If your own Stripe account charges the card, the money was never theirs.
  • The export. Can you download every member's email today, without asking? If not, you are renting the audience.
  • Tiers and caps. Several price points, and a way to cap a small high-touch tier, are what let one community serve both a casual fan and a serious student.
  • Live sessions for members. A craft community needs a room where you can work in front of members and talk beside it, not a public stream.
  • Content rules you can live with. Some platforms allow adult content and carry that reputation; Vibe does not allow it at all.
  • The things you would lose. Podcast hosting, a course builder, a merch shop. Be honest about which of these your income actually runs through.

The full breakdown of every fee model, with worked months, is in creator platform fees. The step-by-step of moving without losing people is in own your audience.

The verified table

PlatformSharePlanAlternatives page
Patreon10% + processingnonePatreon alternatives
Substack10% (keep 90%) + card feesnoneSubstack alternatives
Ko-fi5% memberships and shop; 0% tipsnone; Gold fixed monthlyKo-fi alternatives
Buy Me a Coffeenot published on the homepagenone statedBuy Me a Coffee alternatives
Gumroad10% + $0.50 direct; 30% via DiscovernoneGumroad alternatives
Memberful4.9%$49Memberful alternatives
Kajabi0%$179 / $249 / $499Kajabi alternatives
Teachable7.5% / 0% / 0%$39 / $89 / $189Teachable alternatives
Podia5% / 0% / 0%$42 / $84 / $150Podia alternatives
Circle2% / 1% / 0.5%$89 / $199 / customCircle alternatives
Mighty Networks2% / 1% / 0.5%$79 / $179 / $354Mighty Networks alternatives
Skool10% / 2.9%$9 / $99Skool alternatives
Fourthwall5% memberships; 0% physicalnone; Pro $15Fourthwall alternatives
Discordno pricing page readno pricing page readDiscord alternatives
Facebook Groupsno pricing page readno pricing page readFacebook Groups alternatives
OnlyFansnot published on pages we could readnot publishedOnlyFans alternatives
Vibe0%$0 under $500 a month; then $25 to $999 by supporter countFor creators

Each platform, and why creators leave it

Patreon

The broadest toolset in the group: subscriptions monthly and annual, tiers, one-time payments, hosting for audio, images, text, video and livestreams, newsletters, chats, DMs, analytics, trials, discounts and podcast tools, and it is free to start. Creators leave because the 10% never stops growing with them. Patreon alternatives.

Substack

A newsletter with paid subscriptions attached; writers keep 90% of revenue minus card fees, and it is free to start and free to leave. Creators leave when the work stops being mostly words in an inbox and starts needing video, files and live sessions. Substack alternatives.

Ko-fi

Tips first, with memberships, a shop and commissions added; 5% on those on the free plan, 0% on simple tips, and Gold removes the 5% for a fixed monthly cost. Creators leave when memberships become the main income and the tip-jar framing no longer fits. Ko-fi alternatives.

Buy Me a Coffee

One-off support, memberships, a shop and posts, with a strong stance on ownership: 100% ownership of supporters, no emails sent to them by the platform, and an export at any time. Its fee is not on the homepage, so the number is not here. Creators leave for tiers, live sessions and a wall built for a craft. Buy Me a Coffee alternatives.

Gumroad

A storefront for digital products at 10% plus $0.50 per direct sale, or 30% through its Discover marketplace, with no monthly fee. Creators leave when they want recurring members rather than one-off buyers, or when the Discover rate bites. Gumroad alternatives.

Memberful

A membership tool at $49 a month plus 4.9%, with a Stripe account required. Creators leave when they want the community itself hosted, with a wall and live sessions, rather than a payment layer alone. Memberful alternatives.

Kajabi

A course and business platform with no revenue share, from $179 a month ($143 billed yearly), with its own card processing from 2.9% + $0.30. Creators leave when the plan is the biggest line on the statement and they use a fraction of what it includes. Kajabi alternatives.

Teachable

A course platform: $39 with 7.5%, or $89 and $189 with 0%. Creators leave when the thing they sell is not really a course but a community with live sessions, which a course builder handles poorly. Teachable alternatives.

Podia

A course and membership platform: $42 with 5%, $84 and $150 with 0%, Stripe or PayPal processing at 2.9% + 30 cents on every plan. Creators leave for the same reason as Teachable, or because the entry plan's 5% adds up. Podia alternatives.

Circle

A community platform: $89 with 2%, $199 with 1%, custom with 0.5%. Creators leave when $89 a month is too much for a community that pays them a few hundred, or when they want payments on their own Stripe account. Circle alternatives.

Mighty Networks

Another community platform: $79 with 2%, $179 with 1%, $354 with 0.5%, Pro custom. Creators leave for the plan cost at small sizes and the share at large ones. Mighty Networks alternatives.

Skool

A community platform priced at $9 with 10% or $99 with 2.9%, two months free on both. Creators leave when the 10% on Hobby becomes the biggest cost, or when they want live sessions and a members-only media wall rather than a forum. Skool alternatives.

Fourthwall

Physical products, digital products and memberships under one roof: 5% flat on memberships and digital on the free plan, Pro at $15 removing the digital fee, physical products at cost, 2.9% + 30 cents on US card transactions. Creators leave when memberships outgrow merch. Fourthwall alternatives.

Discord

A chat server organised into channels. We did not read a pricing page for it, so the table has no number. Creators leave when a server full of channels stops feeling like a community and starts feeling like noise, or when they want tiers, a media wall and live sessions for members in one place. Discord alternatives.

Facebook Groups

A group inside a social network, living on that network's feed. No pricing page was read, so no number. Creators leave because the members are Facebook's, not theirs. Facebook Groups alternatives.

OnlyFans

A subscription feed known for adult content. Its fee is not published on pages we could read. Non-adult creators leave because the label follows them; adult creators cannot come to Vibe, which does not allow that content. OnlyFans alternatives.

What you keep out of $100, platform by platform

Vibe$100
Kajabi$100
Circle Professional$98
Mighty Networks Launch$98
Memberful$95.10
Ko-fi Free (membership)$95
Fourthwall (membership)$95
Teachable Starter$92.50
Patreon$90
Skool Hobby$90
Share only, before processing, taxes and plan fees. Every rate from the platform's pricing page, fetched 2026-09-23 (see Sources). Plan fees, which several of these carry, are not in the bar; the table above has them.

What changes on Vibe

A Vibe is one creator's community around a craft. It has a wall for posts, photos, video and files, each public, members-only or sold on its own; up to four tiers with their own prices and inclusions, any of which can be capped; live sessions for members with chat beside the work; tickets for one-off sessions; DMs where the tier includes them; automated welcome, renewal, win-back and premiere emails under your name; a scheduler; and a CSV export of every member's email at any time.

Where most creators are leaving from

  • A share of every payment, or a plan that costs the same in a slow month
  • The platform charges the card and holds the balance
  • An export you have to look for, or that does not exist

Where a Vibe differs

  • 0% of supporter payments; $0 in any month under $500
  • Cards charged on your own Stripe account; Lightning if you want it
  • Every member's email in a CSV, one click, any day

Supporters pick a tier on your page and pay by card. Plans are sized by supporter count only: Free to 49, Build $25 from 50, Grow $125 from 200, Scale $325 from 1,000, Thrive $999 from 5,000, with storage and live viewer-hours included at each step and extras strictly opt-in. Details on the pricing page.

Switching in five steps

  1. Get your list out firstUse whatever export your current platform offers; if it offers none, ask members for an email in a pinned post. Export your member list covers the options.
  2. Open the new home before you say anythingOn Vibe that is an email, a card on file that is never charged, a Stripe connection, and your tiers. No identity check, no fee.
  3. Match or better the old pricesNobody follows you to pay more for the same thing. Add something to the top tier if you can.
  4. Announce with a dateThe reason, the date the old page closes, and what members get by moving. Then post your best new work on the new wall first.
  5. Run both for a month, then closeThe welcome email and renewal reminders on the new platform do most of the retention work.

When staying is the right call

Verdict

Stay if your income runs through a tool only your current platform has, if the fee is still small in absolute dollars, or if your members are the kind who will not follow a link. Move if the platform's cut has become your biggest monthly bill, if you cannot export your members, or if the platform's reputation is costing you work.

Each platform on this page is the right answer for someone. Patreon's podcast tools, Kajabi's course builder, Gumroad's storefront, Substack's inbox and Fourthwall's merch are real, and a creator who lives in one of them should not move for a fee difference of a few dollars. The individual alternatives pages each carry a section on when the platform in question is still the better choice, written to be believed. Read that section before the rest.

Community platform alternatives

A Memberful alternative that takes 0% of what members payMemberful costs $49 a month plus 4.9% of every payment. The alternatives with verified numbers, when Memberful is still the right pick, and what a 0% platform changes.Updated 2026-09-23A Kajabi alternative that takes 0% of what members payKajabi starts at $179 a month and takes no revenue share. The alternatives with verified prices, who Kajabi still suits, and a 0% option that costs $0 in a quiet month.Updated 2026-09-23A Teachable alternative that takes 0% of what members payTeachable's Starter plan is $39 a month plus 7.5% of sales; the 0% plans cost $89 and up. Verified alternatives, when Teachable still wins.Updated 2026-09-23A Podia alternative that takes 0% of what members payPodia's Mover plan is $42 a month plus 5% of sales; Shaker at $84 drops the fee. The alternatives with verified prices, where Podia still fits.Updated 2026-09-23A Circle alternative that takes 0% of what members payCircle starts at $89 a month plus 2% of payments. Verified alternatives for a paid community, when Circle is still the better tool.Updated 2026-09-23A Mighty Networks alternative that takes 0% of what members payMighty Networks starts at $79 a month plus 2% of payments. Verified alternatives, when Mighty is still the right pick.Updated 2026-09-23A Skool alternative that takes 0% of what members paySkool is $9 a month plus 10% on Hobby, or $99 plus 2.9% on Pro. The alternatives with verified numbers, when Skool still fits.Updated 2026-09-23A Fourthwall alternative that takes 0% of what members payFourthwall takes 5% of memberships and digital products on its free plan. Verified alternatives, when Fourthwall is the better tool for merch.Updated 2026-09-23A Discord alternative that takes 0% of what members payDiscord is a chat app, not a membership platform. What to use instead when your community should pay you: verified fees for each option.Updated 2026-09-23A Facebook Groups alternative that takes 0% of what members payA Facebook Group is a place to connect around an interest, not a membership you own. Where to move a paying community, with verified fees for each option.Updated 2026-09-23A Substack alternative that takes 0% of what members paySubstack keeps 10% of what writers earn, before card fees. What the alternatives charge, when Substack is still right, and what a flat plan with 0% taken changes.Updated 2026-09-23A Ko-fi alternative that takes 0% of what members payKo-fi takes 5% on memberships and shop sales on its free plan, 0% on tips. The alternatives with verified fees, when Ko-fi is the better choice, and what Vibe changes.Updated 2026-09-23A Buy Me a Coffee alternative that takes 0% of what members payBuy Me a Coffee does not publish its fee on the pages we could read. What it does say, what the alternatives charge, and when it is still the right choice.Updated 2026-09-23A Gumroad alternative that takes 0% of what members payGumroad takes 10% plus $0.50 per direct sale, 30% through Discover. Alternatives for digital work and memberships, with verified fees, and when Gumroad is still right.Updated 2026-09-23

Questions

What is the cheapest alternative to a revenue-share platform?

On the plan alone, Vibe: $0 in any month under $500 from supporters, then $25 a month from 50 supporters. On a share alone, Kajabi and Vibe both take 0%, but Kajabi's plans start at $179 a month.

Can I take my members with me when I leave a platform?

It depends on the platform's export. Buy Me a Coffee states the list can be exported at any time; on Vibe every member's email exports to CSV in one click. For other platforms, check your account's export before you announce a move.

Does Vibe replace Discord or a Facebook Group?

It replaces the paid part: tiers, a members-only wall, live sessions for members and DMs, with billing on your own Stripe account. Some creators keep a free chat server alongside for the chatter.

Why are Discord, Facebook Groups and OnlyFans missing fees in the table?

We did not read a pricing page for Discord or Facebook Groups, and OnlyFans refuses our fetcher. The table only prints numbers we verified on the platform's own page.

Sources

  1. Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
  2. Substack about checked 2026-09-23
  3. Ko-fi Gold and fees checked 2026-09-23
  4. Buy Me a Coffee homepage checked 2026-09-23
  5. Gumroad pricing checked 2026-09-23
  6. Memberful pricing checked 2026-09-23
  7. Kajabi pricing checked 2026-09-23
  8. Teachable pricing checked 2026-09-23
  9. Podia pricing checked 2026-09-23
  10. Circle pricing checked 2026-09-23
  11. Mighty Networks pricing checked 2026-09-23
  12. Skool pricing checked 2026-09-23
  13. Fourthwall pricing checked 2026-09-23
  14. OnlyFans (fee not readable) checked 2026-09-23