The short answer
Short answer: Decide the one thing members get that followers do not, set two to four tiers with clear inclusions, price the middle tier where a keen hobbyist will not flinch, open the community on a platform whose fee you can predict, then fill it from the audience you already have. Vibe lets you do that for $0 until your supporters pay you $500 in a month.
The eight steps
- Name the promiseOne sentence a member could repeat: "watch me build a piece of furniture every month, get the plans, and ask anything while I work." If the sentence needs a second clause, the community is not clear yet.
- Pick the craft, not the topicA community around woodworking is a room; a community around "creativity" is a lobby. The narrower the craft, the easier the first fifty members are to find, because they are already following you for it.
- Design the tiersTwo to four, each with a price and a list of inclusions a member can check off. One tier can be capped, for example ten seats for critiques of members' own work. The worked example is below.
- Set the pricesPrice the middle tier for the keen hobbyist, the bottom tier for the person who just wants the plans, and the capped tier for the serious few. How to price a membership goes deeper.
- Choose the platform on its fee modelA share, a flat plan, or both. Decide on your own numbers, not the headline. The table further down has the verified rates.
- Open itOn Vibe: an email, a card on file that is never charged, a Stripe connection or a Lightning wallet, your tiers, one post. No identity check and no fee to start.
- Fill it from the audience you already haveThe first fifty come from your existing followers, not from ads. Your first 50 paying members is the playbook.
- Keep themA live session every month, a welcome email, renewal reminders and a win-back note. Retention is a schedule, not a mood.
The worked example: a woodworking Vibe's four tiers
Here is a tier set that a woodworker with a few thousand followers could open this week. The names are the member's benefit, not a metal or a rank. The inclusions are things a member can point to.
| Tier | Price | Inclusions | Cap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plans | $6 a month | every build's plans and cut list as files on the wall; members-only photos | none |
| Workshop | $15 a month | everything in Plans, plus the monthly live build session with chat, and the replays | none |
| Bench | $35 a month | everything in Workshop, plus DMs and a members-only breakdown video of each joint | none |
| Critique | $90 a month | everything in Bench, plus a small live room each month where members' own pieces get reviewed | 10 seats |
Two things to notice. The gap between Plans and Workshop is the live session, which is the thing followers cannot get for free, so it is where most members land. And the top tier is capped, which is what lets it be priced for the serious few without making it feel expensive to everyone else. More tier sets by craft are in membership tiers and pricing and tier ideas for woodworkers.
Open with two tiers if four feels like too much to explain. Add the capped tier once ten people have asked for more of your time; that is the signal it will fill.
What the platform fee does to your price
Members pay the sticker price; you keep the sticker price minus what the platform takes. On a share-based platform that gap is permanent and grows with you. Here is the same $100 of member payments across the models, using each platform's published rate.
For the woodworking example above, suppose 60 members: 25 on Plans, 25 on Workshop, 8 on Bench and 2 on Critique. That is $150 + $375 + $280 + $180, or $985 a month from supporters. On Patreon the platform keeps $98.50 of it, every month, before processing. On Skool Hobby it is $9 plus $98.50. On Vibe it is the Build plan at $25, because 60 supporters sits in the 50 to 199 band and the month is over $500. If the same community had a slow month at $460, Vibe's plan would cost $0. These are fee arithmetic on an example, not a promise of what any community will earn.
Choosing the platform
- Tiers with their own prices and inclusions, and a cap on at least one.
- A wall where posts and files can be members-only or sold on their own.
- Live sessions for members inside the community, with a chat beside the work.
- Automated welcome, renewal and win-back emails under your name.
- An export of every member's email, any day.
- A fee model you can predict a year out.
| Platform | Fee, from its pricing page | Free to start? |
|---|---|---|
| Patreon | 10% of earnings plus processing | yes |
| Ko-fi | 5% on memberships on Free; Gold removes it for a fixed monthly cost | yes |
| Skool | $9 a month plus 10%, or $99 plus 2.9% | two months free on both plans |
| Circle | $89 plus 2%, $199 plus 1%, custom plus 0.5% | no plan under $89 |
| Mighty Networks | $79 plus 2%, $179 plus 1%, $354 plus 0.5% | no plan under $79 |
| Memberful | $49 plus 4.9% | no plan under $49 |
| Vibe | 0%; plan $0 in any month under $500 from supporters, then $25 from 50 supporters | yes, and Free covers up to 49 supporters |
The full list of platforms and their fee models is in creator platform fees, and each pair is compared on the compare hub. Whichever you pick, make sure the export exists before the first member joins.
The first fifty members, week by week
Fifty members is the point where a Vibe moves from Free to Build, and it is also, for most crafts, the point where the community starts to feel like a room rather than an audience. The detailed version, with the messages to send, is in how to get your first 50 paying members.
Keeping members: the part that decides everything
Every paid community loses members; the ones that grow lose fewer than they add. Four habits do most of the work.
Schedule, do not improvise
A live session on the same day each month, a members-only post every week, a file each build. Use the scheduler so a month is planned in one sitting. Members renew for a rhythm they can count on.
Let the emails work for you
On Vibe a welcome note goes to each new member, renewal reminders reach them 7, 3 and 1 days before a charge, a win-back note goes to anyone who lapses, and a premiere announcement goes out when you schedule one. All under your name. Templates are in the welcome email guide and the win-back email guide.
Keep the top tier small
A capped tier stays valuable because it is capped. Ten seats that always sell beat forty that half-fill.
Make leaving easy
A member can cancel from your Vibe page at any time. That sounds like the opposite of retention; it is the reason people join a monthly plan without fear, and the win-back email brings a share of them back.
Communities that stall
- Posts when inspired, sessions when free
- One flat price, so the keen and the casual pay the same
- No email between the sign-up and the cancellation
Communities that renew
- A monthly rhythm members can predict
- Tiers that match how much of you each member wants
- Welcome, reminder and win-back emails on a schedule
What it costs on Vibe
Vibe takes 0% of what supporters pay. Card payments are charged on your own Stripe account, so the money never passes through Vibe; you can also accept bitcoin over Lightning. Plans are sized by how many supporters the community holds: Free up to 49 supporters ($0, with 5 GB of media and 100 live viewer-hours a month), Build $25 from 50 (50 GB, 500 viewer-hours), Grow $125 from 200 (250 GB, 2,000 viewer-hours), Scale $325 from 1,000, Thrive $999 from 5,000. In any month where supporters pay you under $500, the plan costs $0; at $500 or more, that month's plan fee is billed when the month ends. Extra storage and viewer-hours exist but are opt-in only, and nothing is charged unless you switch it on.
Three mistakes that end paid communities early: opening with no live element, so members cannot tell what they are paying for beyond the free feed; pricing the bottom tier so low that it becomes the only tier anyone picks; and choosing a platform without checking that you can export your members, so that leaving later means starting over.
Nothing here promises what a community will earn. What it promises is that the cost side is knowable in advance, which is more than a share-based platform can say. Check your own numbers on the calculator and the plan grid on the pricing page.
Questions
How many members do I need before starting a paid community?
Fewer than you think. The first members come from the people who already comment and ask questions. Ten of them is enough to hold a first live session that feels like a room; the goal is fifty, which is the point at which most crafts feel like a community.
How much should I charge for a paid community?
Price the middle tier where a keen hobbyist will not hesitate, put a cheaper tier under it for people who only want the files, and cap a higher tier for the serious few. The worked example on this page runs $6, $15, $35 and $90 for a woodworking community; adjust for your craft.
What does it cost to start a paid community on Vibe?
Nothing to start: no identity check, no fee, and a card on file that is never charged. Vibe takes 0% of supporter payments, and the plan costs $0 in any month your supporters pay you under $500.
Do members pay Vibe or pay me?
They pay you. A supporter picks a tier on your Vibe page and pays by card on your own Stripe account, or over Lightning to your own wallet. Vibe never holds the money.
Can I leave with my members if it does not work out?
Yes. Every member's email exports to CSV in one click, any day.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Ko-fi Gold and fees checked 2026-09-23
- Skool pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Circle pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Mighty Networks pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Memberful pricing checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-23