The short answer
Short answer: Substack's own site states that writers keep 90% of their revenue minus credit card fees, so the platform's share is 10%. The alternatives are either other revenue-share platforms with a smaller share, plan-plus-share platforms, or a flat plan with 0% taken, which is what Vibe is. Which is cheapest depends on how much your readers pay you each month, not on the platform.
Every figure here was read from the platform's own page on the date under Sources, and where a page does not give a number, this one does not either.
What Substack charges, and what you get for it
Substack's about page puts it in one line: writers keep 90% of their revenue minus credit card fees. It is free to start and free to leave, and there are no platform fees or tiers until a writer earns money. In practice that is a revenue-share model with no plan: nothing until the first paid subscriber, then 10% of every payment after, with card fees on top.
What you get is a writing and publishing tool with the paywall built in, and the newsletter as the delivery mechanism. For a writer whose product is the writing, that fit is hard to beat, and the free-to-leave promise is a real one that not every platform makes plainly.
At $1,000 a month from paid readers, 10% is $100 a month. At $4,000 it is $400. The share does not shrink as you grow, which is the whole argument for looking at a plan instead once the numbers get serious.
The alternatives, with verified numbers
| Platform | Share of each payment | Monthly plan | Shape |
|---|---|---|---|
| Substack | 10% (writers keep 90%) minus card fees | none | Newsletter with paywall |
| Patreon | 10% plus processing, conversion and payout fees | none | Tiered membership, posts, livestreaming, podcast tools |
| Ko-fi | 5% on memberships and shop on Free, 0% on simple tips | none on Free; Gold is a fixed monthly cost that removes the 5% | Tips, memberships, shop |
| Memberful | 4.9% | $49 Standard | Membership layer on your own site; Stripe account required |
| Circle | 2% / 1% / 0.5% | $89 / $199 / custom | Community platform |
| Vibe | 0% | $0 in any month under $500 from supporters; otherwise $25 to $999 by supporter count | Community around a craft: wall, four tiers, live sessions, tickets, DMs |
The side-by-side with Patreon specifically, for writers weighing the two, is at Patreon vs Substack; the two-column version against Vibe is Vibe vs Substack.
What a Vibe gives a writer that a newsletter does not
A Vibe is a creator's community around a craft, and writing is a craft. The room has a wall for posts, photos, video and files, each of which can be public, members-only, or sold on its own, so a single essay or a guide can be bought without a subscription. It has up to four tiers with their own prices and inclusions, so a reader who wants more than the writing has somewhere to go. It has live sessions for members with chat beside the work, tickets for one-off sessions such as a workshop or a reading, and direct messages where a tier includes them.
The emails still go out. Welcome notes, renewal reminders at 7, 3 and 1 days, win-back notes and premiere announcements are sent under your name, and the whole member list, every email, comes out as a CSV whenever you want it. Payments are charged on your own Stripe account and Vibe keeps 0% of them; you can also accept bitcoin over Lightning. Nothing is owed to Vibe in a month where your supporters pay you under $500.
- Wall posts: public, members-only, or sold on their own
- Up to four tiers, any of which can be capped
- Live sessions and tickets, inside the Vibe for its members
- Every member's email exportable to CSV, one click
- 0% of payments taken; a flat plan sized by supporter count
When Substack is the better choice
Stay on Substack if your product is the writing and the newsletter is how people read it. Move if your readers have become members who want a room, a session and things to buy, and the 10% has become your largest monthly cost.
Substack is the right tool when the newsletter is the product. The writing, the inbox delivery and the paywall are one thing, the reader's experience is exactly what a newsletter reader expects, and there is nothing to set up beyond the writing itself. A writer with a growing paid list and no interest in running live sessions or selling anything but the words has little reason to leave, and the free-to-leave promise means there is no penalty for staying until the day that changes.
The case for moving begins when the words stop being the whole product. If your paid readers ask for a live session, a place to talk to each other, a file they can download, or a way to buy one piece without subscribing, you are running a community on a newsletter tool, and paying 10% for the privilege. At that point the arithmetic is worth ten minutes: run your numbers on the calculator.
Moving from Substack
Get your paid readers' emails out first, using whatever export your account offers, before you announce anything, and keep a copy off the platform. Open the Vibe with the same price as your paid subscription, or slightly better, and put your best archive on the wall members-only so early arrivals find the writing they came for. Announce once with the reason and a date, run both for a month, and close the old paid tier to new joiners at the end of it. The week-by-week version is in moving from Substack, and the general method, including what to do when a platform has no export, is in own your audience.
Questions
How much does Substack take?
Substack's about page states that writers keep 90% of their revenue minus credit card fees, which is a 10% platform share. It is free to start and free to leave, with no platform fees until a writer earns money.
Is Vibe a newsletter platform?
No. A Vibe is a community around a craft, with a wall, tiers, live sessions and tickets. It does email members under your name for welcomes, renewals, win-backs and premieres, and every member's email exports to CSV.
What does Vibe charge instead of a share?
A flat plan sized by how many supporters the Vibe holds, from Free up to 49 supporters to $999 from 5,000. Any month where supporters pay you less than $500 costs $0, and Vibe takes 0% of payments.
Can readers pay for one piece without subscribing?
On Vibe, yes. A wall item can be sold on its own, to members and non-members alike.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Substack about checked 2026-09-23
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Ko-fi Gold and fees checked 2026-09-23
- Memberful pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Circle pricing checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-23