Vibe

A Fourthwall alternative that takes 0% of what members pay

Fourthwall is a merch and membership storefront for creators: physical products, digital products and memberships, with no plan to pay. The memberships side carries a 5% flat fee on its free plan. If merch is a sideline and the membership is the business, that 5% is the wrong number to be paying. This page sets out the alternatives, with each platform's printed fee.

The short answer

Short answer: Fourthwall charges a 5% flat fee on memberships and on digital products on its free plan, no percentage on physical products (product costs are deducted instead), and 2.9% + 30 cents payment processing on US card transactions; its Pro plan at $15 a month removes the digital product fee. Vibe takes 0% of memberships on every plan and charges a flat plan that is $0 in any month your supporters pay you under $500.

Fourthwall's figures are from fourthwall.com/pricing on the date under Sources. Note that Pro removes the fee on digital products; the pricing page we read did not say it removes the fee on memberships, so this page does not claim that.

5%of memberships on Fourthwall's free plan
$15a month for Fourthwall Pro, which removes the digital product fee
0%of memberships on Vibe, every plan

How Fourthwall's fees work

Fourthwall separates three kinds of sale. Physical products carry no percentage; instead the product cost is deducted from the sale price and the creator keeps the margin. Digital products carry a 5% flat fee on the free plan, and Pro at $15 a month removes it. Memberships carry a 5% flat fee on the free plan. Payment processing on US card transactions is 2.9% + 30 cents on top.

For a creator whose income is mostly merch, this is a fair shape: no plan, no percentage on the physical goods, a margin on each shirt. For a creator whose income is mostly memberships, it means 5% of every renewal, every month, with processing on top, and no published plan that turns it off.

The arithmetic

A membership of 200 people at $10 a month is $2,000. Fourthwall's 5% is $100 a month, or $1,200 a year, before processing. The same community on Vibe is on Grow at $125 a month, or on Build at $25 if it is under 200, with 0% taken, and $0 in any month under $500.

The alternatives, on printed numbers

PlatformMonthly planFee on membershipsMerch or shop
Fourthwallnone, or Pro $155% flatPhysical products with costs deducted; digital 5% (0% on Pro)
Ko-finone, or Gold at a fixed price5% (0% on Gold)Shop sales 5% on the free plan
Gumroadnone10% + $0.50 per direct saleDigital products; 30% via Discover
Patreonnone10% + processingNot verified for this page
Buy Me a Coffeenone statedNot published on the page we readShop listed
Memberful$494.9%No
Vibe$0 to 49 supporters, then $25 to $999 by size; $0 under $500 a month0%Files and video sold on their own from the wall; no physical merch

Buy Me a Coffee's homepage does not state its fee percentage, so no number is given here. Ko-fi's Gold price was not on the page we read.

One $100 membership, side by side

Vibe$100
Memberful$95.10
Fourthwall$95
Ko-fi (membership)$95
Patreon$90
Gumroad (direct)$89.50
Out of $100 a member pays, before card processing and taxes. Fees from each platform's pricing page, fetched 2026-09-23 (see Sources). Monthly plans, where they exist, are not in the bars.

Fourthwall sits with Ko-fi at 5%, which is half of Patreon's share and a real saving for a creator who came from there. It is still $5 of every $100, forever. On Vibe the bar is full and the plan is paid as rent, which is cheaper or dearer depending on your size; the calculator settles it for your numbers.

Running the membership on Vibe and the merch elsewhere

Vibe does not print shirts. What it does is run the membership: supporters open your Vibe page, pick one of up to four tiers, pay by card on your own Stripe account, and get the wall, the live sessions and whatever else the tier includes. Nothing stops a creator keeping a merch store on a store platform and linking to it from the wall.

Membership on a storefront

  • 5% of every renewal, with processing on top
  • The membership is a tab beside the products
  • Live sessions and tiers depend on what the storefront offers

Membership on Vibe

  • 0% of every renewal; a flat plan waived under $500 a month
  • The membership is the whole page: wall, tiers, live sessions, DMs
  • Files and video sold on their own from the wall; merch links out

A Vibe also sends the emails a membership needs, under your name: welcome, renewal reminders at 7, 3 and 1 days, win-back, premiere announcements. Every member's email exports to CSV in one click. Every photo and video a member receives carries an invisible mark unique to that account. You can also accept bitcoin over Lightning, for supporters who prefer it.

When Fourthwall is the better choice

Verdict

Keep Fourthwall if merch is the business and the membership is a bonus for buyers. Move the membership if it is the business and merch is the bonus.

Fourthwall's real product is the store: physical goods with the product cost deducted from each sale and no percentage on top. A creator whose audience buys shirts, prints and mugs is well served by that, and paying 5% on a small memberships tab beside it is not worth a second platform.

The picture flips when memberships are most of the income. Then 5% of every renewal is the largest fee the creator pays, and it buys a storefront they mostly use for its memberships tab. That creator gets a better room, and keeps the whole payment, on a platform built for the membership. The direct comparison is at Vibe vs Fourthwall, and the wider field is on the community platform alternatives hub.

Questions

What does Fourthwall charge?

Its pricing page lists a 5% flat fee on memberships and on digital products on the free plan, no percentage on physical products (product costs are deducted instead), 2.9% + 30 cents payment processing on US card transactions, and a Pro plan at $15 a month that removes the digital product fee.

Does Fourthwall Pro remove the membership fee?

The pricing page we read says Pro removes the fee on digital products. It did not say the membership fee is removed, so this page does not claim it.

Can I sell merch on Vibe?

Not physical merch. Files and video on your wall can be sold on their own. A merch store on another platform can be linked from the wall.

What does a membership cost to run on Vibe?

0% of what supporters pay, plus a flat plan by supporter count: Free up to 49, Build $25 from 50, Grow $125 from 200, Scale $325 from 1,000, Thrive $999 from 5,000. A month under $500 from supporters costs $0.

Keep the whole payment.

Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.

Sources

  1. Fourthwall pricing checked 2026-09-23
  2. Ko-fi Gold and fees checked 2026-09-23
  3. Gumroad pricing checked 2026-09-23
  4. Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
  5. Buy Me a Coffee checked 2026-09-23
  6. Memberful pricing checked 2026-09-23

Last updated 2026-09-23