The short answer
Short answer: Creator platforms charge in three ways: a share of what you earn, a flat monthly plan, or a plan plus a smaller share. Which is cheapest depends on how much your members pay you each month, so compare on your own numbers rather than on the headline rate.
The table below covers every platform we have verified so far. A cell that says a number was not published means exactly that: the platform's own page did not state it, or refused to be read, and we would rather leave a gap than fill it with a rumour. Each row's source and fetch date is under Sources at the end.
One table, every verified fee
| Platform | Share of your revenue | Monthly plan | Processing on top |
|---|---|---|---|
| Patreon | 10% of earnings on Patreon | none, free to start | yes, plus currency conversion and payout fees |
| Substack | 10% (writers keep 90%) | none, free to start and free to leave | credit card fees |
| Ko-fi | 5% on memberships, shop and commissions (Free); 0% on simple tips; 0% on Gold | none on Free; Gold is a fixed monthly cost not shown on the page we read | card processing fees |
| Buy Me a Coffee | not published on the homepage we read | none stated | not stated |
| Gumroad | 10% + $0.50 per direct sale; 30% via Discover | none | not separately stated |
| Memberful | 4.9% | $49 Standard; Enterprise custom | a Stripe account is required |
| Kajabi | 0% | $179 Basic / $249 Growth / $499 Pro ($143 / $199 / $399 billed yearly) | 2.9% + $0.30, 2.8% + $0.30, 2.7% + $0.30 by plan; extra 2%, 1% or 0.5% with a third-party processor |
| Teachable | 7.5% on Starter; 0% on Builder and Growth | $39 / $89 / $189 ($29 / $69 / $139 annually); custom plan available | standard processing fees |
| Podia | 5% on Mover; 0% on Shaker and Earthquaker | $42 / $84 / $150 ($504 / $1,008 / $1,800 a year) | 2.9% + 30 cents via Stripe or PayPal |
| Circle | 2% Professional / 1% Business / 0.5% Plus | $89 / $199 / custom | not stated on the pricing page |
| Mighty Networks | 2% Launch / 1% Scale / 0.5% Growth and Pro | $79 ($950 a year) / $179 / $354 / custom | not stated on the pricing page |
| Skool | 10% Hobby / 2.9% Pro | $9 / $99, two months free on both | not separately stated |
| Fourthwall | 5% on memberships and digital products (Free); Pro removes the digital product fee; 0% on physical products, product costs deducted instead | none on Free; Pro $15 | 2.9% + 30 cents on US card transactions |
| OnlyFans | not published on pages we could read | not published | not published |
| Vibe | 0% | $0 until supporters pay you $500 in a month; then $25 Build / $125 Grow / $325 Scale / $999 Thrive, sized by supporter count | Stripe's own processing on your own Stripe account |
Two notes on reading the table. Kajabi's zero share is real, but its entry plan is $179 a month, so it is a flat plan in the way rent is flat. Vibe's zero share is also real, and its plan is $0 in any month under $500 from supporters, so a small community pays nothing at all until it is not small.
How to read a comparison without being misled
Four things go wrong in most platform comparisons. Knowing them turns a marketing page into a useful one.
1. The headline rate hides the plan
Skool's Pro plan takes 2.9%, which sounds close to Circle's 2%. But Skool Pro is $99 a month and Circle Professional is $89, and both charge that whether you earned $50 or $5,000. A rate without its plan fee is half a price.
2. The plan hides the rate
The reverse trap. Teachable's Starter plan looks cheap at $39 a month, but it carries a 7.5% transaction fee; Builder at $89 drops the fee to 0%. Podia's Mover at $42 takes 5%; Shaker at $84 takes nothing. Whether the cheaper plan is actually cheaper depends entirely on what your members pay you.
3. Processing gets counted twice, or not at all
Every platform passes card processing on in some form. Patreon lists it beside its 10%. Kajabi prints its own rates by plan. Podia prints 2.9% + 30 cents. On Vibe, charges are made on your own Stripe account, so Stripe's processing is Stripe's and Vibe adds nothing to it. When one page includes processing and another excludes it, the comparison is off by about three points before you start.
4. Marketplace fees are a different number
Gumroad charges 10% plus $0.50 on a direct sale, and 30% when the buyer came through its Discover marketplace. A creator comparing Gumroad to a membership platform should ask which of those two numbers applies to their sales.
Any comparison that does not show the source and the date for each number is asking you to trust it. Prices on these pages change without notice; ours were fetched on 2026-09-23 and the links are at the bottom so you can re-check.
What stays with you out of $100
The share is the part of the price that scales with you, so it deserves its own picture. Plan fees are left out of the bars and handled in the next section, because a plan is a fixed number and a share is not.
Three months, priced on every model
Here is the same arithmetic applied to three sizes of month. These are illustrations of the fee formulas, not predictions about what any creator will earn. Processing is left out of every column so the models can be compared cleanly.
| Members pay you | Patreon (10%) | Skool Hobby ($9 + 10%) | Circle Professional ($89 + 2%) | Memberful ($49 + 4.9%) | Kajabi Basic ($179) | Vibe |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $400 from 40 members | $40 | $49 | $97 | $68.60 | $179 | $0 (under $500) |
| $2,000 from 120 members | $200 | $209 | $129 | $147 | $179 | $25 (Build) |
| $6,000 from 350 members | $600 | $609 | $209 | $343 | $179 | $125 (Grow) |
Read across the middle row and the pattern is clear: the share-based platforms cost the most once a community pays real money, the plan-plus-share platforms sit in the middle, and the flat plans win at the top. The Vibe column is small because the plan is sized by supporter count, not by revenue, and because a month under $500 costs nothing. Put your own figures into the calculator; it uses these same verified rates.
Vibe versus each platform
Each of these pages puts Vibe beside one platform in a two-column table on verified facts, and says plainly what the other platform does better.
Two platforms, head to head
If you are choosing between two platforms that are not Vibe, these pages compare them on their own numbers, with a third column for Vibe only where it changes the answer.
Patreon against the field
- Patreon vs Substack
- Patreon vs Ko-fi
- Patreon vs Buy Me a Coffee
- Patreon vs Memberful
- Patreon vs Gumroad
- Patreon vs Kajabi
- Patreon vs Circle
- Patreon vs Skool
- Patreon vs Fourthwall
- Patreon vs Discord
Tips, newsletters and storefronts
Course platforms
Community platforms
Where Vibe sits in this table
Vibe is a creator's community around a craft. It belongs in the flat-plan column with Kajabi, with two differences that matter for a comparison. The plan is sized by how many supporters the community holds rather than by a feature list, and a month in which supporters pay the creator under $500 costs $0 on every plan. Free covers up to 49 supporters with 5 GB of media and 100 live viewer-hours; Build is $25 a month from 50 supporters; Grow $125 from 200; Scale $325 from 1,000; Thrive $999 from 5,000.
A share-based platform
- Cost rises with every new member
- The platform is the merchant of record
- Payout on the platform's calendar
Vibe
- 0% of supporter payments, no application fee, ever
- Card charges land on your own Stripe account
- $0 in any month under $500 from supporters
Supporters pick a tier on your page and pay by card; you can also accept bitcoin over Lightning. Every member's email exports to CSV in one click. What Vibe does not have is a podcast toolset, a course builder with quizzes, or a merch shop, and a creator whose income runs through those should weigh that honestly in the alternatives hub before choosing.