Vibe

Memberful vs Substack

Memberful and Substack are both places a writer or podcaster lands when it is time to charge readers. They ask different things of you. Substack gives you a finished publication and takes a tenth. Memberful adds paid memberships to a site and tools you already run, and charges a monthly plan plus a smaller fee. One of those trades is cheaper for you, and it depends on a single number. The other difference, whose platform your work lives on, depends on you.

What it comes down to

Short answer: Substack is cheaper below roughly $961 a month in member revenue, because it charges no plan and keeps 10%; above that, Memberful's Standard plan at $49 a month plus a 4.9% transaction fee leaves you more. Choose Substack for a ready-made publication and Memberful for memberships on your own site and domain, connected to your own Stripe account.

$49 + 4.9%Memberful Standard, per month plus per transaction
10%Substack's share; writers keep 90% minus card fees
~$961of monthly revenue where the two cost the same

Card processing is left out of the arithmetic. Substack's card fees come off the writer's 90%, and Memberful's page, as we read it, gives no processing rate beyond its own 4.9%.

Rent plus a small share, or a share and no rent

The crossover is where $49 plus 4.9% of revenue equals 10% of revenue: 5.1 points have to cover $49, which happens at about $961. Here is the gap on either side of it.

Member revenue a monthSubstack (10%)Memberful ($49 + 4.9%)Difference
$300$30.00$63.70Substack cheaper by $33.70
$600$60.00$78.40Substack cheaper by $18.40
$961$96.10$96.09Even
$2,000$200.00$147.00Memberful cheaper by $53
$5,000$500.00$294.00Memberful cheaper by $206

Memberful also has an Enterprise plan at custom pricing, which is not modelled here. The deeper breakdown of its rate is on Memberful fees.

Your site, or Substack's

Memberful plugs into what you run

  • Custom domains
  • Integrations with WordPress, Mailchimp, Discord and Kit
  • A Stripe account of your own is required
  • Unlimited members on Standard

Substack is the whole publication

  • Written posts delivered to readers
  • Native podcast hosting, published to Apple, Spotify and YouTube
  • Live video and subscriber chat
  • Comment threads with moderation tools

The left column assumes you already have a home: a WordPress site, an email tool, maybe a Discord server. Memberful adds the paid layer to it. The right column assumes you want the home provided. Substack hands you the publishing, the podcast feed and the chat in one package, and asks for nothing until you earn.

What Memberful's Standard plan lists

A large part of Memberful's plan is about keeping members once they have joined, which is where most membership revenue is won or lost.

  • Apple Pay and Google Pay at checkout
  • Coupons, free and paid trials, group plans and one-time payments
  • Monthly, annual or weekly billing
  • A referral program, retention discounts and cancellation surveys
  • Podcasts, newsletters, communities, courses and downloads

Substack's about page does not describe trials, coupons or retention tools, so this page does not claim it has or lacks them. What it does describe is a publishing platform with no platform fees, no tiers and no contracts until paid subscriptions begin.

When Substack is the better choice

Substack is the better choice for a writer or podcaster starting from nothing, or earning less than about $960 a month from readers. There is no plan to pay in a slow month, no site to maintain and no integrations to wire up, and podcast distribution to the big apps comes with it. For someone who wants to write and let the platform handle the rest, the higher share is the cost of that simplicity. If you outgrow it later, Moving from Substack covers the switch.

When Memberful is the better choice

Verdict

Substack for a new or small publication that wants everything provided. Memberful for an established creator with a site, an email list and steady revenue above about $961 a month, who wants memberships on their own domain.

Memberful wins once revenue is steady and the creator already owns the pieces. At $5,000 a month it costs $206 less than Substack's share, before processing, and the retention tools (trials, coupons, referral program, cancellation surveys, retention discounts) work to keep that revenue. Billing weekly, monthly or annually and selling group plans gives more ways to price than a single subscription.

Your own Stripe, and a third option

Memberful's requirement of your own Stripe account is worth pausing on, because it is the same arrangement Vibe uses. On Vibe, supporters pick a tier and pay by card, and the charge is made on the creator's own Stripe account; Vibe never holds the money and takes 0% of it. Instead of a transaction fee, the creator pays a flat plan by community size, from $0 for up to 49 supporters to $999 a month, and nothing in a month when supporters pay under $500.

Vibe$100
Memberful$95.10
Substack$90
Kept from each $100 a member pays, before card fees and taxes. Memberful from its pricing page, Substack from its about page (see Sources). Memberful's and Vibe's plans are billed separately.

Vibe vs Memberful goes through the rest of that comparison.

Questions

What does Memberful cost?

Its pricing page lists the Standard plan at $49 a month plus a 4.9% transaction fee, with Enterprise at custom pricing. A Stripe account is required.

Is Memberful cheaper than Substack?

Above about $961 a month in member revenue, yes, before card processing. Below that, Substack's 10% share with no plan costs less.

Can I use Memberful with WordPress?

Memberful's pricing page lists integrations with WordPress, Mailchimp, Discord and Kit, and custom domains, on the Standard plan.

Does Substack charge before I earn?

No. Its about page says it is free to start and free to leave, with no platform fees or tiers until a writer earns money.

Keep the whole payment.

Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.

Sources

  1. Memberful pricing (plan price, transaction fee, Stripe requirement) checked 2026-09-23
  2. Memberful pricing (Standard plan features) checked 2026-09-24
  3. Substack about (fees) checked 2026-09-23
  4. Substack about (podcasts, live video, chat, comments) checked 2026-09-24

Last updated 2026-09-26