Vibe

Patreon vs Gumroad

Patreon sells time: a member pays every month to stay close. Gumroad sells things: a buyer pays once for a file, a course or a licence. The two headline rates look identical at 10%, and the details underneath are not, which is why a creator who does both keeps asking which to lean on. This page uses each company's own pricing page and nothing else for the numbers.

The short answer

Short answer: Patreon keeps 10% of the income you earn on it, plus processing, currency conversion and payout fees. Gumroad keeps 10% plus $0.50 on each direct sale, and 30% on sales that come through its Discover marketplace, with no monthly fee. Use Patreon for recurring membership, Gumroad for one-off digital products.

Both are free to start and both are paid from what you earn. The $0.50 per sale on Gumroad matters more on cheap products than on dear ones, and the 30% Discover rate applies only when the marketplace brought the buyer.

Vibe$100
Patreon$90
Gumroad, direct sale$89.50
Gumroad, Discover sale$70
Out of $100 a supporter or buyer pays, before card processing and taxes. Rates from Patreon's and Gumroad's pricing pages, fetched 2026-09-23. Vibe takes 0% and bills a flat plan separately, $0 in any month under $500 from supporters.

The verified table

PatreonGumroad
Platform share10% of income earned on Patreon10% + $0.50 per direct sale; 30% on Discover sales
Monthly planNoneNone
Also chargedPayment processing, currency conversion, payout fees, taxesNot itemised on the pricing page beyond the rates above
ModelRecurring membership, monthly and annual, tiers, one-time paymentsSales of products; a marketplace that can bring buyers at a higher rate
Features namedAudio, image, text, video and livestream hosting, newsletters, chats, DMs, comments, analytics, trials, discounts, podcast toolsThe pricing page states rates, not a feature list

Gumroad's page is a rate card, so its feature cell is empty on purpose. What the rate card says is enough to plan with: a tenth plus fifty cents when the buyer came from you, and three tenths when Gumroad's marketplace found them.

Time versus things

The useful way to choose is by what your supporters are paying for. If they pay to stay close, to get the next post, the live stream, the chat, the early access, that is a membership, and Patreon is built for it: tiers with different inclusions, annual billing, trials, sales, hosting for every media type, chats and DMs, member analytics and podcast tools, per its pricing page.

If they pay for a thing, a preset pack, an ebook, a font, a course they keep, that is a sale, and Gumroad is built for it: a product page, a checkout, a file delivered, and a marketplace that can send buyers you did not have, at a price. The two are not rivals so much as neighbours, and plenty of creators run both.

Patreon for

  • Recurring income from members
  • Video, audio, livestreams, podcasts
  • Community: chats, DMs, comments

Gumroad for

  • One-off digital products and licences
  • Buyers who arrive from your own links
  • Discover, when 30% for a new buyer is worth it

What the fifty cents does

Gumroad's $0.50 per direct sale is small until the product is. On a $50 product the platform keeps $5.50, or 11%. On a $5 product it keeps $1.00, or 20%. On a $2 product it keeps $0.70, which is 35%. Creators selling cheap files in volume feel this; creators selling a $200 course do not. Patreon's share has no fixed per-payment amount, so a $2 tier costs the same tenth as a $50 one, before processing.

Watch out

The Discover rate is 30%, not 10%. If a buyer reaches your Gumroad product through the marketplace, the platform keeps three times as much on that sale. Decide whether the marketplace's reach is worth it for each product rather than leaving it on by default.

The third column: a community that also sells files

A creator who wants both, a membership and files sold one at a time, has a third shape to consider. On Vibe, a wall carries posts, photos, video and files, and each one can be public, members-only or sold on its own; up to four tiers carry the recurring side; live sessions run inside the Vibe for members and one-offs can sell tickets. The platform takes 0% of memberships, tickets or file sales. The creator pays a flat plan by headcount, $0 up to 49 supporters and $0 in any month under $500 from supporters, then $25, $125, $325 or $999 by community size. Payments land on the creator's own Stripe account, and a creator can also accept bitcoin over Lightning. There is no marketplace, so there is no Discover-style rate either; buyers arrive from your links, as they do on a direct Gumroad sale. The full case against Patreon's tenth is on Patreon alternatives, and the calculator runs your own numbers against every rate on this page.

When Patreon is the better choice, and when Gumroad is

Verdict

Patreon is the better choice when your income is recurring and your supporters want an ongoing relationship with media and chat. Gumroad is the better choice when you sell finished digital products, especially at prices where fifty cents does not sting, and when its marketplace brings buyers you could not reach.

Patreon's advantage is everything a membership needs in one place: tiers, annual plans, trials and sales, native hosting for video, audio and livestreams, newsletters, chats, DMs, comments, analytics and podcast tools. It costs a tenth and there is nothing to assemble.

Gumroad's advantage is that a sale is simple and final: one product, one price, one file, and a marketplace that can find buyers for you at 30% when you want it. For finished work at a fair price, that is the cleaner tool, and there is no monthly fee to think about. If you run both a community and a shop and would rather the platform took nothing from either, the flat-plan options are on the comparison hub with every verified rate side by side.

Questions

What does Gumroad charge?

Its pricing page states 10% plus $0.50 per direct sale, 30% on sales through its Discover marketplace, and no monthly fee.

What does Patreon charge?

10% of the income a creator earns on Patreon, plus payment processing, currency conversion, payout fees and applicable taxes, with no monthly fee.

Can I use Patreon and Gumroad together?

Yes. Many creators run a Patreon membership for recurring support and a Gumroad shop for one-off products. Each platform's fee applies to the payments made on it.

Is there a way to sell files and run a membership with no percentage taken?

On Vibe, files and video on the wall can be sold on their own alongside up to four membership tiers, and Vibe takes 0% of any of it. The creator pays a flat plan by community size, $0 in any month under $500 from supporters.

Keep the whole payment.

Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.

Sources

  1. Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
  2. Gumroad pricing checked 2026-09-23

Last updated 2026-09-23