The short answer
Short answer: Patreon keeps 10% of your income with no monthly fee. Memberful's Standard plan is $49 a month plus a 4.9% transaction fee, requires your own Stripe account, and its Enterprise plan is custom priced. Below roughly $960 a month from members the two cost about the same; above it, Memberful is cheaper and the gap widens.
The crossover figure is arithmetic on the published rates: at $960 a month, 10% is $96, and $49 plus 4.9% of $960 is also about $96. Card processing is left out on both sides because both pass it on.
Verified, side by side
| Patreon | Memberful | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly plan | None | Standard $49; Enterprise custom |
| Share of payments | 10% of income earned on Patreon | 4.9% transaction fee |
| Also charged | Payment processing, currency conversion, payout fees, taxes | Stripe's processing, on your own Stripe account |
| Who is the merchant | Not stated on the pricing page | You; a Stripe account is required |
| Where members live | On Patreon | On your own site, behind Memberful's paywall |
| Features named | Tiers, monthly and annual, one-time payments, media hosting, livestreams, newsletters, chats, DMs, comments, analytics, trials, discounts, podcast tools | Pricing and Stripe requirement are what the page we read states |
Memberful's pricing page is short, so its feature cell is short. It does not host your content; it gates content you host elsewhere, which is the whole idea and the reason it wants your own Stripe account.
Three sizes, two bills
A share and a plan behave differently as you grow, so a single number is misleading. Here are three communities on published rates only.
| Members pay you | Patreon (10%) | Memberful ($49 + 4.9%) |
|---|---|---|
| $400 a month | $40 | $69 |
| $2,000 a month | $200 | $147 |
| $8,000 a month | $800 | $441 |
Small communities pay less on Patreon because there is no rent. Once a community earns past the crossover, Memberful's smaller percentage wins and keeps winning. What neither column shows is the cost of building and running the site Memberful sits on, which is real and yours.
A flat plan with 0% taken sits below both lines once a community earns anything: on Vibe, the same three communities would pay $0 (under $500 in the month), $25 on Build, and $125 on Grow for a room of 200 or more, with nothing taken from the $8,000. The calculator plots all three with these rates.
Destination or toolkit
Patreon is a destination. Members come to Patreon, some already have an account and a card there, and the creator gets a full product with hosting, tiers, trials, sales, chats and analytics without owning any infrastructure. The cost is the tenth, and a relationship that runs through Patreon's pages.
Memberful is a toolkit. It plugs into a site you already run, gates the parts you choose, charges on your own Stripe account and stays out of the way. The cost is $49 a month plus 4.9%, and the work of owning a website. Creators with an established site and a technical friend love it; creators who want to post and be paid by Friday tend not to.
Patreon suits
- No website of your own, or no wish to run one
- Video, audio, podcast and livestream hosting under one roof
- A community earning under the crossover
Memberful suits
- An existing site with content worth gating
- Charging on your own Stripe account
- A community earning well past the crossover
Where a paid community platform sits between them
A creator who likes Memberful's idea, your own Stripe account, your own list, a smaller cut, but does not want to run a website is the creator a paid community platform is for. On Vibe, supporters pick a tier and pay by card on the creator's own Stripe account, Vibe takes 0%, and the plan is by headcount: $0 up to 49 supporters, $25 from 50, $125 from 200, $325 from 1,000, $999 from 5,000, with any month under $500 from supporters costing $0. The room itself has a wall, up to four tiers, live sessions for members, tickets, DMs where the tier includes them, automated emails under the creator's name and a one-click CSV of every member. That comparison against Patreon in full is on Patreon alternatives.
When Patreon is the better choice, and when Memberful is
Patreon is the better choice for a creator without a site who wants the whole membership product and earns under about $960 a month from members. Memberful is the better choice for a creator with a site to gate, a Stripe account to charge on, and income comfortably past that line.
Patreon wins on completeness and on the empty-month case. There is no bill in a quiet month, the hosting for video, audio and livestreams is included, podcast tools and newsletters are there, and disputes and failed payments are handled for you. For a new membership that is a lot of value for nothing up front.
Memberful wins on ownership and on scale. The charge lands on your own Stripe account, the members are on your site, and 4.9% beats 10% by a widening margin as income grows, even after the $49. The price is that you bring the site and keep it running. If neither shape fits, the comparison hub has every platform's verified rate in one table, including the ones that take 0%.
Questions
How much does Memberful cost?
Its pricing page lists a Standard plan at $49 a month plus a 4.9% transaction fee, and an Enterprise plan at custom pricing. A Stripe account is required.
At what income is Memberful cheaper than Patreon?
On published rates, at about $960 a month from members: 10% of $960 is $96, and $49 plus 4.9% of $960 is also about $96. Above that Memberful's bill is lower, before card processing on both.
Does Memberful host my content?
Its pricing page describes a plan and a Stripe requirement, not hosting. Memberful gates content on a site you run; Patreon's pricing page lists hosting for audio, images, text, video and livestreams.
Is there an option with your own Stripe account and no percentage?
Vibe charges on the creator's own Stripe account, takes 0%, and bills a flat plan by community size that is $0 in any month under $500 from supporters.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Memberful pricing checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-23