The short answer
Short answer: Patreon keeps 10% of the income you earn on it, plus payment processing, currency conversion, payout fees and taxes. Substack says writers keep 90% of revenue minus credit card fees. The fee is a wash; pick Patreon for a tiered membership around video, audio and community, and Substack for a paid newsletter.
Both figures are from the platforms' own pages, fetched on the date under Sources. Neither charges a monthly plan: the platform's share comes off each payment, and it grows as you do.
Fees and features, verified
| Patreon | Substack | |
|---|---|---|
| Platform share | 10% of income earned on Patreon | 10% (writers keep 90%) |
| On top | Payment processing, currency conversion, payout fees, applicable taxes | Credit card fees |
| Monthly plan | None; free to start | None; free to start and free to leave |
| Tiers | Multiple tiers, monthly and annual, one-time payments | Not stated on the page we read |
| Media | Audio, images, text, video, livestreaming, podcast tools | Not stated on the page we read |
| Community | Chats, DMs, comments, member analytics | Not stated on the page we read |
| Promotions | Free trials, discounts and sales | Not stated on the page we read |
Substack's about page is a statement of principles rather than a feature list, so its column is thin by design. Where it says "not stated", this page does not guess. What the page does say clearly is the money: free to start, free to leave, no platform fees or tiers until a writer earns, and 90% kept after that.
What each one is for
Patreon is a membership platform. Its pricing page lists monthly and annual subscriptions, multiple tiers, one-time payments, hosting for audio, images, text, video and livestreams, email newsletters, chats, DMs and comments, member analytics, free trials, discounts and sales, and podcast tools. A creator who posts video, runs a podcast, streams and wants a community layer around it is squarely who Patreon serves.
Substack is a publishing platform. The unit is the post that lands in an inbox, and the paid layer is the subscriber who pays to receive more of them. A writer whose work is words, delivered on a schedule, is who Substack serves, and the fact that free readers and paid readers live on the same list is a large part of why it works for writing.
Patreon suits
- Video, audio and podcast creators
- Tiered memberships with different inclusions
- Creators who want chats and DMs with members
Substack suits
- Writers with a regular newsletter
- One paid tier on top of a free list
- Creators whose readers live in their inbox
The same $100, three ways
Because both take a tenth, the bar chart looks like a tie. The third bar is here because some creators reading this page are weighing a platform that charges a flat plan instead of a share, and the difference only shows when you put it next to the other two.
On Vibe, supporters pick a tier and pay by card on the creator's own Stripe account, and the plan is $0 up to 49 supporters, then $25, $125, $325 or $999 a month by community size. Whether that beats a 10% share depends on your numbers; the calculator runs them with these rates.
Where the third column matters
For a writer sending a newsletter, Substack's share buys distribution and an inbox habit that a community platform does not replace, and this page does not argue otherwise. For a creator running a community around a craft, with live sessions, a wall of posts and files, and tiers that can be capped, the comparison with Patreon is the one to make: the same tiered membership, but the platform takes 0% and charges rent by headcount instead. That trade is laid out in full on Patreon alternatives.
A share is cheapest when you are small and dearest when you are large. A flat plan is the reverse. If your community pays you a few hundred dollars a month, the share barely registers; at a few thousand, it is your biggest bill.
When Patreon is the better choice, and when Substack is
Choose Patreon if your work is video, audio or a podcast and you want tiers with different inclusions plus chat with members. Choose Substack if your work is writing and you want free and paid readers on one list. Look at a flat-plan community platform if the tenth has become your largest monthly cost.
Patreon is the better choice for anyone whose supporters expect more than words: native video and livestream hosting, podcast feeds, multiple tiers, one-time payments, free trials and sales, and chats and DMs, all under one roof. It also handles the mechanics of a membership business for you, which is worth a lot to a creator who has never chased a failed payment.
Substack is the better choice for a writer. The free list and the paid list are the same list, the post arrives in the inbox where readers already are, and there is nothing to set up beyond writing. Free to start and free to leave, as its about page says, and 90% kept after card fees. Neither platform is wrong; they are built for different work. Every platform's verified numbers, including the flat-plan ones, sit side by side on the comparison hub.
Questions
Is Substack cheaper than Patreon?
On the platform share, no: Patreon keeps 10% of earnings and Substack writers keep 90%. Patreon's page also lists payment processing, currency conversion, payout fees and taxes on top; Substack's lists credit card fees.
Is either one free to start?
Both. Patreon states there is no monthly fee and the fee is a percentage of earnings. Substack states it is free to start and free to leave, with no platform fees until a writer earns money.
Which is better for a podcast?
Patreon lists podcast tools and hosting for audio on its pricing page. Substack's about page does not describe podcast features, so this page makes no claim about them.
What if I do not want to pay a share at all?
Vibe takes 0% of what supporters pay and charges a flat plan by community size instead, with $0 owed in any month under $500 from supporters. It is built for a community around a craft rather than a newsletter.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Substack about checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-23