The short version
Short answer: Substack keeps 10% of paid subscription revenue (writers keep 90% minus credit card fees); Gumroad takes 10% plus $0.50 on each direct sale and 30% on sales through its Discover marketplace, and neither charges a monthly fee. Substack suits a writer selling a subscription to a publication; Gumroad suits a creator selling files, courses or a membership from a store.
The effective rate at small prices
A fixed charge weighs more on a cheap sale than on an expensive one. Here is Gumroad's direct fee as a share of the price, next to Substack's flat tenth, from $3 to $50.
| Price | Gumroad direct fee | As a share of the price | Substack's 10% |
|---|---|---|---|
| $3 | $0.80 | 26.7% | $0.30 |
| $5 | $1.00 | 20% | $0.50 |
| $10 | $1.50 | 15% | $1.00 |
| $20 | $2.50 | 12.5% | $2.00 |
| $50 | $5.50 | 11% | $5.00 |
A $5 monthly membership sold directly on Gumroad gives up a fifth of every payment. The same $5 as a Substack subscription gives up a tenth, plus the card fee. If your price is low and your volume high, that 50 cents is the most important number on either pricing page. The Gumroad fees answer works through more cases.
Card fees: read both pages closely
The comparison above is not the whole bill. Substack's about page says writers keep 90% minus credit card fees, so a card charge comes out of the writer's side on top of the 10%. Gumroad's pricing page, as we read it, lists no separate card-processing charge next to its 10% plus 50 cents.
At low prices Gumroad's fixed 50 cents is the heaviest item on either side. At higher prices, once Substack's card fees are added, the gap narrows and can close or reverse. Neither page gives enough to settle it exactly, so compare a real payout statement from each before you move a product.
Discover, a marketplace with a price tag
Gumroad charges 30% when a customer finds you through Discover, its marketplace, instead of your own profile or link. That is three times the direct rate. One way to read it: advertising that only bills when it produces a sale. Another: a tax on buyers you could have sent there yourself. Both are fair, and the difference is whether Discover brings you people you would never have reached.
Substack's about page describes a single share for every paying reader and names no separate rate for readers found one way or another. For a creator who hates surprises in the fee line, that simplicity counts.
Tax and payouts
Gumroad's pricing page says that since January 1, 2025 it handles sales tax collection and remittance worldwide, and that creators are paid by direct deposit or PayPal depending on their country. For someone selling a template to buyers in dozens of countries, having tax handled is a real saving of time and worry.
Substack's about page does not address tax handling or payout methods, so this page makes no claim about either. If international tax matters to your plans, check Substack's terms before deciding.
What each one sells
Substack sells access to a publication: written posts, podcasts hosted natively and published to Apple, Spotify and YouTube, live video, a subscriber chat and comment threads with moderation tools. The subscriber pays for the stream of work and the conversation around it.
Gumroad sells things: digital products, e-books, courses and memberships, each bought at a checkout from a store. A membership there is one product on a shelf, next to one-off files. A creator can have reasons to use both: a newsletter on one, a shelf of templates on the other.
When Substack is the better choice
Substack is the better choice when you publish on a schedule and want readers, subscribers and the work in one place. Its share has no fixed per-sale part, which protects low prices, and podcasts, live video, chat and comments come included. It is free to start and free to leave. Moving from Substack is there if you later outgrow it.
When Gumroad is the better choice
Substack for a newsletter or podcast with paid subscribers, especially at low prices. Gumroad for a shelf of files, e-books or courses at prices where 50 cents barely registers, sold to buyers in many countries.
Gumroad is the better choice when you sell a thing rather than a stream. From $25 up its direct fee stays within two points of a tenth, sales tax is handled worldwide, and Discover can reach buyers you had no way to find, at 30% when it does.
Selling single posts without a per-sale fee
Between a publication and a store sits a third shape: a community around a craft, where some work is for members and some is sold on its own. On Vibe, each post, photo, video or file on the wall can be public, members-only or sold by itself, and Vibe takes 0% of any of it. The creator pays a flat plan by supporter count instead ($0 up to 49 supporters, then $25 to $999 a month), and a month in which supporters pay under $500 costs nothing. Vibe vs Gumroad compares the two, and the calculator tests your own numbers.
Questions
Why does Gumroad cost more on cheap products?
Because of the fixed $0.50 on each direct sale. On a $5 sale, 10% plus $0.50 is $1.00, an effective 20%. On a $50 sale it is $5.50, an effective 11%.
What is Gumroad Discover's fee?
Gumroad's pricing page lists 30% on sales made through its Discover marketplace, against 10% plus $0.50 on direct sales.
Does either one charge a monthly fee?
No. Gumroad's pricing page lists no monthly fee, and Substack's about page says there are no platform fees until a writer earns money.
Does Gumroad handle sales tax?
Its pricing page says that since January 1, 2025 Gumroad handles sales tax collection and remittance worldwide. Substack's about page does not address tax.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Substack about (fees) checked 2026-09-23
- Substack about (podcasts, live video, chat, comments) checked 2026-09-24
- Gumroad pricing (fees, no monthly fee) checked 2026-09-23
- Gumroad pricing (products, sales tax, payouts, card processing) checked 2026-09-24
Last updated 2026-09-26