The short answer
Short answer: Circle's plans are Professional at $89 a month with a 2% transaction fee, Business at $199 with 1%, and Circle Plus at custom pricing with 0.5%. Vibe charges a flat plan by community size, from $0, takes 0% of payments, and waives the plan in any month your supporters pay you under $500.
Circle's numbers are from circle.so/pricing on the fetch date under Sources. The platforms listed alongside it are the ones a creator actually weighs against Circle: other community tools, and the membership platforms people start on before they outgrow them.
How Circle charges
Circle uses the plan-plus-share model at every tier. Professional is $89 a month and takes 2% of member payments. Business is $199 a month and takes 1%. Circle Plus is custom priced and takes 0.5%. The percentage never reaches zero on any published plan, and the plan never reaches zero either.
That is a deliberate design: Circle is priced for organisations as much as for creators. A company running a customer community, a coaching business with a team, a course brand with thousands of students: for them $199 a month is a line item and 1% is nothing. For one person running a woodworking community of 150 members at $15 a month, $89 plus 2% of $2,250 is $134 a month, which is nine members' payments.
On Vibe, that same community of 150 is on Build at $25 a month with 0% taken, and the $25 is only charged in a month where supporters paid you $500 or more.
Community platforms compared on verified numbers
| Platform | Monthly plan | Share of payments | Live sessions for members |
|---|---|---|---|
| Circle | $89 / $199 / custom | 2% / 1% / 0.5% | Not verified for this page |
| Mighty Networks | $79 / $179 / $354 / custom | 2% / 1% / 0.5% / 0.5% | Not verified for this page |
| Skool | $9 / $99 | 10% / 2.9% | Not verified for this page |
| Patreon | none | 10% + processing | Livestreaming listed |
| Memberful | $49 | 4.9% | Attaches to your own site |
| Kajabi | $179 / $249 / $499 | 0% + processing | Not verified for this page |
| Vibe | $0 up to 49 supporters, $25 from 50, $125 from 200, $325 from 1,000, $999 from 5,000 | 0% | Yes, with chat beside the work, tickets for one-offs |
Where the last column says not verified, the platform may well offer it; this page only states what the pricing page we read said. Fee columns are as printed on each pricing page.
What each leaves from $100
Circle's share is small, and the bars say so honestly. The cost of Circle is the plan, and the plan is what the bars cannot show. Put your member count and price into the calculator and compare the year, not the payment.
A Vibe, for a creator who was looking at Circle
Circle's appeal is that it feels like a real product for your members: organised, branded, quiet. A Vibe is built to the same standard for a narrower job, which is a paid community around one craft, run by one creator.
- A wall for posts, photos, video and files, each public, members only, or sold on its own.
- Up to four tiers with their own price and inclusions, and the option to cap a tier at a fixed number of seats.
- Live sessions for members with chat beside the work and a goal the room can see; tickets for one-off sessions.
- Direct messages where the tier includes them, and a scheduler for posts and sessions.
- Automated emails under your name: welcome, renewal reminders at 7, 3 and 1 days, win-back, premiere announcements.
- A CSV of every member's email in one click, any day.
Supporters open your Vibe page, pick a tier and pay by card; the charge is on your own Stripe account and the money never passes through Vibe. You can also accept bitcoin over Lightning. Storage and live time are included in the plan: 5 GB and 100 viewer-hours a month on Free, 50 GB and 500 on Build, 250 GB and 2,000 on Grow, with more on Scale and Thrive, and extras only if you switch them on.
Moving a community off Circle
- Export what you can from CircleMember list first. Circle's export options were not verified for this page; check your admin settings before you announce anything.
- Open the Vibe and mirror your tiersSame prices or slightly better, so nobody feels they are paying more to follow you. Up to four tiers, one of them capped if you want a small-group option.
- Announce the date and the reasonOne post on Circle, one email. The reason can be as plain as the fee.
- Run both for a monthLet renewals move on their own schedule. Close Circle when the last active members are across.
The full playbook, with what to write and when, is in Own your audience.
When Circle is the better choice
Choose Circle if you are running a community for an organisation, with a team, multiple spaces and a need for structure that one creator's room does not have. Choose Vibe if you are that one creator and the plan plus percentage is the largest cost you carry.
Circle is strong where Vibe does not go: many spaces under one roof, admin roles for a team, integrations with the rest of a business's stack, courses alongside the community, and a member experience designed to carry a brand rather than a person. A coaching company, a software firm's user community or a large course business gets real value from that, and at their scale the plan is not the issue.
The mismatch is a solo creator paying an organisation's price for a room that only needs one host. If that is you, the two-column version is at Vibe vs Circle, and the other community tools are on the alternatives hub.
Questions
How much does Circle cost?
Circle's pricing page lists Professional at $89 a month with a 2% transaction fee, Business at $199 a month with 1%, and Circle Plus at custom pricing with 0.5%.
Does Circle take a percentage of member payments?
Yes. Its published plans take 2%, 1% or 0.5% of payments depending on the plan, on top of the monthly price.
Is Vibe free?
The Free plan covers up to 49 supporters at $0. Every plan takes 0% of payments, and every plan costs $0 in a month where supporters pay you under $500.
Can members message me on Vibe?
Direct messages are available where a tier includes them. You decide which tiers carry that.
Can I run live sessions on Vibe?
Yes. Live sessions happen inside your Vibe for its members, with chat beside the work and a goal the room can see. You can also sell tickets to one-off sessions. There is no public livestream directory.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Circle pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Mighty Networks pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Skool pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Memberful pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Kajabi pricing checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-23