Vibe

Cette page n’est pas encore traduite. Elle est affichée en anglais.

Vibe vs Circle

Circle and Vibe are both community platforms, so this is the comparison where the rooms look alike and the bills do not. Circle's Professional plan is $89 a month plus 2% of every payment; Business is $199 plus 1%; Circle Plus is custom priced plus 0.5%. Vibe's plans run from $0 to $999 by supporter count, take 0% at every level, and cost nothing in a month under $500 from supporters.

The answer

Short answer: Circle charges a plan and a share: $89 a month plus 2% on Professional, $199 plus 1% on Business, custom pricing plus 0.5% on Circle Plus. Vibe charges a plan and no share: $0 up to 49 supporters, $25 from 50, $125 from 200, and $0 in any month supporters pay you under $500.

Both are built for a creator who wants members in one place with posts, spaces or tiers, and live sessions. Circle's pricing page is unusually detailed about what each plan holds, so the table below can be precise. All Circle figures are from that page, fetched 2026-09-23.

$89 + 2%Circle Professional, a month, plus a share of each payment
$199 + 1%Circle Business
$25 + 0%Vibe Build, from 50 supporters
$0Vibe in a month under $500 from supporters

Two bills that grow differently

Circle's fee is small in percentage terms and it shrinks as you pay more rent: 2%, then 1%, then 0.5%. But it is still a share, so it rises with every payment your members make, on top of a plan that starts at $89. A community paying $2,000 a month on Professional costs $89 plus $40, so $129. At $5,000 it is $189. Move to Business to halve the share and the plan alone is $199.

Vibe's bill has one component and it does not move with revenue. A community of 150 supporters is on Build at $25 whether those supporters pay $1,500 or $6,000 in the month. A community of 400 is on Grow at $125. The only revenue rule is the threshold: under $500 from supporters, the month is free.

Vibe$100
Circle Business$99
Circle Professional$98
Out of $100 a member pays, before card processing and taxes. Circle's transaction fees from circle.so/pricing, fetched 2026-09-23 (see Sources). Both platforms' monthly plans are billed separately and are not in the bars.
The rent is the story

Circle's share is among the smallest percentages on this site, so the comparison is really $89 or $199 against $25 or $125, plus whether a slow month costs you anything. On Circle it always does. On Vibe it costs $0 under $500.

Plan by plan

ItemVibeCircle
Transaction fee0%2% Professional, 1% Business, 0.5% Circle Plus
Monthly plan$0 Free, $25 Build, $125 Grow, $325 Scale, $999 Thrive$89 Professional, $199 Business, custom Circle Plus
What sets the planSupporter count (49, 50+, 200+, 1,000+, 5,000+)Admins, moderators, spaces, storage, features; members unlimited on all plans
Bill in a quiet month$0 under $500 from supportersThe plan fee
Storage5 GB Free, 50 GB Build, 250 GB Grow, more above; 1 TB extra for $125 a month200 GB, 500 GB, 1 TB
LiveSessions for members with chat and a visible goal; 100, 500 or 2,000 viewer-hours a month by plan, extra at $25 per 1,000 at 720p30Live streams up to 100 or 200 attendees; live rooms up to 15 or 20 participants; flexible on Plus
AdminsNot stated on Vibe's pages3 / 5 / unlimited
SpacesA Vibe: a wall, up to four tiers, DMs, sessions20 / 30 / unlimited
CoursesNoIncluded
Money pathCharged on your own Stripe account; Vibe never holds itNot stated on the pricing page
Media protectionInvisible per-account mark on every photo and videoNot on the pricing page
Member exportEvery email to CSV, one click, any dayNot on the pricing page
BitcoinOptional, over LightningNot on the pricing page

Circle's page also lists a custom domain, Circle AI credits, workflows and automated transcriptions on Professional and Business, AI agents on Business, custom SSO and optional branded apps on Plus, and a 30-day money-back guarantee. Vibe does not offer branded apps, SSO or a course builder.

Live, measured two ways

Both platforms run live sessions for members, but they meter them differently. Circle caps the room: 100 attendees on a Professional live stream, 200 on Business, and 15 or 20 participants in a live room. Vibe caps the hours: 100 viewer-hours a month on Free, 500 on Build, 2,000 on Grow, where a viewer-hour is one person watching for one hour. Two hundred members watching a one-hour session use 200 viewer-hours; the same 200 people at four sessions in a month use 800, which fits Grow with room to spare, and on Build would need extra hours at $25 per 1,000 at 720p30 or $125 per 1,000 at 1080p60, switched on by you.

Inside a Vibe session the chat sits beside the work and the room can see a goal. One-off sessions can be ticketed, and the recording goes to the wall for whoever missed it. Every video a member receives carries an invisible mark unique to that account, on every plan, so a leaked recording identifies where it came from.

Month 1Forty supporters pay you $360. Vibe: Free plan, $0. Circle Professional: $89 plus 2%, so $96.20.
Month 6Ninety supporters pay you $900. Vibe: Build, $25. Circle Professional: $89 plus $18, so $107.
Month 12Two hundred and forty supporters pay you $2,600. Vibe: Grow, $125. Circle Professional: $89 plus $52, so $141; Business: $199 plus $26, so $225.

How a member joins a Vibe

A supporter opens the creator's page, picks a tier and pays by card. Nothing else is asked of them. The charge is made on the creator's own Stripe account through direct charges, so Vibe never holds the money and takes none of it; Stripe pays the creator's bank on its schedule. Memberships renew monthly, reminders go out at 7, 3 and 1 days before renewal, and a member can cancel from the page whenever they like. Creators who want it can also accept bitcoin over Lightning, to their own wallet.

Up to four tiers each carry their own price and inclusions, and any tier can be capped, for example ten seats for critiques of members' own work. Direct messages come with the tiers that include them. Emails for welcomes, renewals, win-backs and premieres go out under the creator's name, and every member's email exports to CSV any day. The calculator shows which Vibe band your community lands in.

When Circle is the better choice

Verdict

Choose Circle if you need many spaces, several admins and moderators, a course builder, workflows or a branded app, and your community is big enough that $89 or $199 a month is a small line. Choose Vibe if the community is a creator and their craft, you want no share taken at any size, and you want a bill that vanishes in a slow month.

Circle is the more elaborate product. Its pricing page lists 20 to unlimited spaces, up to unlimited admins and moderators, courses, events, live streams, AI credits, workflows on Business, and branded apps and SSO on Plus. An organisation running a multi-space community with a team behind it will find things there that Vibe simply does not have. Its transaction fee is also among the lowest percentages on this site, so for a large community the share matters less than the plan.

Vibe is the better fit for a single creator with a single community around what they make. One wall, up to four tiers, live sessions with chat and a goal, marked media, member email under your name, and a plan from $25 that takes 0% and costs $0 under $500 a month. For other community tools with their verified rates, see the Circle alternatives page; the comparison hub lists every pairing on this site.

Questions

What does Circle cost?

Circle's pricing page lists Professional at $89 a month with a 2% transaction fee, Business at $199 with 1%, and Circle Plus at custom pricing with 0.5%, all with unlimited members.

Does Vibe limit members like Circle limits admins and spaces?

Vibe's plan band is set by supporter count: Free up to 49, Build from 50, Grow from 200, Scale from 1,000, Thrive from 5,000. Storage and live viewer-hours scale with the band. Vibe takes 0% on every band.

How do live sessions compare?

Circle caps attendees per stream (100 on Professional, 200 on Business). Vibe meters viewer-hours per month (100 on Free, 500 on Build, 2,000 on Grow), where one viewer-hour is one person watching for one hour, with extra hours available as an opt-in.

Do I pay Vibe in a month with little income?

No. On every plan, a month in which supporters pay you less than $500 costs $0.

Keep the whole payment.

Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.

Sources

  1. Circle pricing checked 2026-09-23

Last updated 2026-09-23