The short answer
Short answer: If your gardening work is mostly writing, a newsletter platform such as Substack fits. If you run a community with planting calendars, garden-walk video, live sessions for members and help with members' own plots, a membership platform fits better. Vibe is one: it keeps 0% of what members pay, and a month in which your supporters pay you under $500, such as a quiet winter month, costs $0.
A grower's year is uneven
If your membership grows in spring and thins in winter, that is not a failure. It is the craft. The platform question is which fee model lives comfortably with it.
How each fee model behaves in a quiet month
A fixed plan with no floor
- The same monthly bill in January as in May
- A slow winter can mean paying more than the membership brings in
- Worth it for a large, steady community
A share, or a plan with a floor
- A share shrinks with a quiet month, but grows every busy one
- Vibe's plan is $0 in any month under $500 from supporters
- Each month is judged on its own
| Platform | What it charges, from its own pricing page | In a slow month |
|---|---|---|
| Substack | Writers keep 90% of revenue minus card fees; free to start | The share falls with revenue |
| Patreon | 10% of earnings plus processing and payout fees; no monthly fee | The share falls with revenue |
| Skool | Hobby $9 a month with a 10% transaction fee; Pro $99 with 2.9% | The plan price stays; the fee falls |
| Mighty Networks | Launch $79 a month with a 2% transaction fee; higher plans cost more with a lower fee | The plan price stays; the fee falls |
| Vibe | 0% of supporter payments; a flat plan by supporter count, $25 to $999 | $0 if supporters pay you under $500 that month |
The share-based platforms cost little in winter and the most in your best spring. The plan-based ones cost the same all year. Vibe takes no share in any month and bills its plan only for a month at or over $500. To see which comes out cheaper across your own twelve months, run your numbers on the calculator, and the platform fees guide has the wider comparison.
What a growing community needs
- Files for planting calendars, bed layouts and rotation plans, members-only or sold on their own to non-members.
- Video hosting for garden walks. Phone footage from a morning round of the beds adds up quickly over a season, so check the storage: 5 GB on Vibe's Free plan, 50 GB on Build, 250 GB on Grow.
- Live sessions for members, for seed starting in February and pest questions in July. A viewer-hour is one person watching for one hour, so forty members at a one-hour session use forty of Build's 500 a month.
- A small, capped tier for help with members' own plots, with direct messages switched on for that tier.
- Tickets for one-off sessions such as a winter pruning class, which bring in people who are not members yet.
- A scheduler, so spring posts can be written in February when you have the time and released when the garden needs them.
- Renewal reminders at 7, 3 and 1 days, and win-back emails under your name for the members who drifted away over winter.
A Vibe has each of these, with storage and viewer-hours sized by your plan. Supporters pick a tier on your page and pay by card, charged on your own Stripe account, and you can also accept bitcoin over Lightning.
When a newsletter or a group platform is the better choice
A grower whose work is a weekly letter, read in an inbox, is well served by Substack's model; its about page also lists podcasts, live video and subscriber chat. A grower building courses with a very cheap start may prefer Skool's Hobby plan. A grower whose members want the planting plans, the garden walks, live sessions and help with their own beds is the case Vibe is built for.
Whatever you pick, keep a copy of your members' emails; on Vibe every member's email exports to CSV in one click. How tiers work across a gardening year is in tier ideas for gardeners and growers, and neighbouring crafts are sorted on the best platform by craft.
Questions
Will I pay Vibe in winter if my membership is small?
Not if your supporters pay you under $500 that month. Any month under $500 costs $0 on every plan; each month is judged on its own.
Is Substack good for gardening writers?
If the work is a newsletter, yes. Substack states writers keep 90% of revenue minus card fees, with no platform fees until a writer earns money. For live sessions and files inside a membership, a community platform fits better.
Can members ask about problems in their own garden?
On Vibe you can switch on direct messages for a tier, so members can send you a link to photos of a problem. A capped tier keeps that manageable.
What does Skool cost?
Skool's pricing page lists Hobby at $9 a month with a 10% transaction fee and Pro at $99 a month with a 2.9% transaction fee.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Substack about checked 2026-09-23
- Substack about: features checked 2026-09-24
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Skool pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Skool pricing: features checked 2026-09-24
- Mighty Networks pricing checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-27