The short answer
Short answer: Offer a $5 tier of outtakes and stories behind the shot, a $15 tier of editing walkthroughs with the source files, a $35 critique tier capped at twenty with a monthly live session, and a $150 mentorship capped at three. The price should rise with how much of your attention a member gets, not with how many photos they see.
| Tier | Price a month | Seats | What members get |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contact Sheet | $5 | Open | The frames that did not make the cut, the story behind each shoot, settings and gear notes |
| Edit Room | $15 | Open | Contact Sheet, plus a monthly editing walkthrough video and the source file to follow along |
| Critique Night | $35 | 20 | Edit Room, plus a monthly live critique where members' own images are reviewed |
| Mentorship | $150 | 3 | Critique Night, plus direct messages with you and a say in what you teach next |
What belongs at each level
Contact Sheet, $5
Your followers already see the hero frame. What they never see is the forty frames around it: the one where the light had not arrived yet, the one where the subject blinked, the one you almost chose. Post a shoot's contact sheet with a few paragraphs about the day, the settings and why the final frame won. It is cheap to make, because you shot it anyway, and it teaches more than the finished image does.
Edit Room, $15
A monthly video of you editing one image from raw to finished, with the file posted so members can work along. Photographers learn editing by copying a real edit, step by step, then trying their own version. Keep each walkthrough to one image and one idea (recovering a sky, matching skin tones across a set) so members actually finish it.
Critique Night, $35, capped at 20
Once a month, a live session inside your Vibe where you review members' own photos. Chat runs beside the work, so the whole room learns from each critique, and a goal the room can see keeps the evening moving, such as reviewing every member's frame before the hour is out. Twenty seats is about the number you can review with care in one evening. When it fills, hold the line and open a second night.
Mentorship, $150, capped at 3
Direct messages are included in this tier, so a mentee can send a set from last weekend's wedding and ask what to fix before delivering it to the client. Three is a deliberate number: enough to be worth running, few enough that each person feels they have your ear. Let mentees suggest the next Edit Room topic, which keeps your teaching aimed at real problems.
What to hold back
Do not put personal feedback in an uncapped tier. The first time forty people send you a portfolio in the same week, your own shooting stops.
- Full-resolution originals for everyone. Keep heavy files for the tier that pays for the work of preparing them. Everyday posts can be sized for the screen.
- Every edit you ever make. One good walkthrough a month beats four rushed ones.
- Unlimited critique. One image per member per critique night keeps the session fair and on time.
Members-only images on Vibe carry an invisible mark unique to each member's account, on every plan, so a leaked copy identifies the account it was delivered to. Mention that in the tier description; it is part of what makes sharing finished work with members comfortable.
One-off sessions as tickets
Not everything fits a monthly rhythm. A portfolio review before submission season, a night on printing and paper choice, a session on pricing a first wedding: sell each with a ticket for a one-off session. An Edit Room member who has never had their own frames reviewed finds out what a critique feels like, and you learn how many portfolios fit in an hour before you commit to a monthly cap.
- Launch with Contact Sheet and Edit RoomTwo tiers you can produce from work you already do.
- Run one ticketed critiqueSee how many images you can review well in an hour before you set the Critique Night cap.
- Open Critique NightCap it at the number that ticketed session taught you.
- Add Mentorship lastOffer the three seats to members who already send thoughtful questions.
Where the money comes from
Take a hypothetical roster, invented to show the shape rather than to predict yours: 100 on Contact Sheet ($500), 50 in the Edit Room ($750), 20 at Critique Night ($700) and 3 mentees ($450) is 173 members and $2,400 in a month.
Vibe takes 0% of the $2,400. Each photographer who joins chooses a tier on your page and pays by card, and the charge runs on your own Stripe account, paid straight to you. You can also accept bitcoin over Lightning. Run your own numbers in the calculator. To choose where the membership lives, read the best platform for photographers; general pricing rules are in membership tiers and pricing.
Questions
What should the cheapest photography tier include?
Material you already have: outtakes, the story of each shoot and your settings. Keep critique and personal feedback for higher, capped tiers.
How many people can a live critique session handle?
Roughly as many images as you can review with care in an hour. Run a ticketed session first, then cap the tier at that number.
Are my members-only photos protected on Vibe?
They are traceable rather than locked. Each photo and Edit Room video a member receives carries a hidden mark tied to that member's account, so if one surfaces on a free forum you know whose copy it was. Nothing prevents every copy.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-27