The short answer
Short answer: Offer three or four tiers, not one and not eight: a cheap way in, a middle tier that holds most of what you make, a higher tier with access to you, and a capped top tier with a seat count people can see. Price the middle tier at what a member would pay for one good thing a month, and price the top tier by scarcity, not by content.
A membership is not a product with one price. It is a ladder, and every rung answers a different question a supporter is asking. The bottom rung answers is this worth trying. The middle rung answers is this worth keeping. The top rungs answer how close to the maker can I get. Get the questions right and the prices mostly write themselves.
The four-rung ladder
Here is the shape that holds up across cooking, fitness, woodworking, photography, music and most other crafts. The names are placeholders; use your own.
| Rung | Job of the tier | What goes in it | Typical share of members |
|---|---|---|---|
| Supporter | A cheap way in and a thank-you | Members-only posts on the wall, early access to public work, the community itself | Largest by headcount |
| Member | The working tier; this is where the value lives | Everything above plus the full archive, files and templates, replays of live sessions | Most of the money |
| Insider | Access to you | Everything above plus live sessions with chat, direct messages, a monthly question thread you answer | A committed minority |
| Studio (capped) | Scarce, personal, visibly limited | Everything above plus critique of the member's own work, a small live room, a seat count such as ten | A handful, and a waiting list |
Two tiers is too few because it forces a supporter who wants to spend a little more to leave instead. Six or more is too many because every extra rung splits the same value thinner and makes the choice harder. Three is fine if you are starting out; add the capped tier when you have something personal to sell.
Write each tier as a sentence a member would say to a friend: "I pay for the recipes and the Sunday cook-along." If you cannot write that sentence, the tier is not clear enough yet.
How much to charge
Nobody can hand you a number, and any page that does is guessing. What you can do is anchor each tier to something your members already buy.
The middle tier
Ask what one good thing from you would cost on its own: a pattern, a class ticket, a preset pack, a training plan. That is roughly the monthly price of the Member tier, because a member should feel they get at least one of those every month. If a single pattern sells for $8, a $10 monthly tier that includes every pattern is easy to justify. If a workshop ticket is $40, a $25 tier that includes the replay looks like a deal.
The bottom tier
Low enough that price is not the reason someone says no, high enough that it still feels like a decision. This rung exists to turn a follower into a member; it is not where you make money.
The upper tiers
Price access to you by your time. A live session for members costs you an hour whether five or fifty people watch, so the Insider tier can be priced modestly. Critique of a member's own work costs you an hour per member, so the capped tier should be priced like a service, and the seat cap is what keeps it sane.
What the platform's fee does to your price
On a platform that keeps a share, the price you set is not the price you receive. Patreon's pricing page states it keeps 10% of a creator's earnings plus processing and payout fees, so a $10 tier is a $9 tier before processing. On a flat plan, the tier price is what lands on your own Stripe account. Before you settle on a ladder, run your numbers on the calculator, and see how to price a membership for the longer argument.
The capped top tier
The single most useful pricing tool in a craft community is a tier with a visible seat limit. Ten seats, eight seats, twenty: the number matters less than the fact that members can see it and see when it is full.
An uncapped top tier
- Priced by how much content is in it
- Grows until you cannot serve it
- Nobody hurries to join; it will be there next month
A capped top tier
- Priced by scarcity and your time
- Never outgrows the hours you have
- A full tier with a waiting list sells the tier below it
On Vibe, any tier can be capped, for example ten seats for critiques of members' own work. Fill it with the kind of thing that only works small: feedback on a member's own project, a live room where everyone gets a turn, direct messages where the tier includes them. The guide to limited-seat tiers goes into how to set the number and what to do when it fills.
Do not cap a tier and then quietly raise the cap when it fills. Members notice, and the scarcity that made it sell disappears. Open a second capped tier at a different time slot instead.
Example ladders by craft
These are starting points, not rules. Each craft has its own page with the full ladder and the reasoning.
Cooking
- Supporter: the recipe of the week, members-only, plus early access to public videos
- Member: the whole recipe archive, printable cards, the Sunday cook-along replay
- Insider: the live cook-along itself, with chat beside the pan, and direct messages
- Table (capped at ten): a monthly small-room session where members cook the same dish and get their plates critiqued
Full ladder: tier ideas for cooking classes.
Fitness coaching
- Supporter: the weekly workout post and the community
- Member: every programme as a file, the form-check library, session replays
- Insider: live sessions with the goal visible to the room, and a monthly question thread
- Squad (capped): a small live room with individual form checks
Full ladder: tier ideas for fitness coaches.
Woodworking
- Supporter: the build log, members-only
- Member: plans and cut lists as files, the full archive, replays
- Insider: live builds with chat, direct messages for tool questions
- Bench (capped): critique of the member's own piece from their photos
Full ladder: tier ideas for woodworkers.
Photography
- Supporter: behind-the-shoot posts
- Member: presets and editing files, the archive, edit-along replays
- Insider: live edit sessions, direct messages
- Darkroom (capped): portfolio reviews of the member's own images
Full ladder: tier ideas for photographers.
Monthly, one-off, and things sold on their own
A ladder does not have to carry everything. Some things sell better outside the membership than inside it.
On Vibe, memberships renew monthly, a member can cancel from your page at any time, and reminders go out before a renewal at 7, 3 and 1 days. Alongside the tiers, three other price points exist: a wall item can be sold on its own (a single pattern, a full-length video, a file bundle), a live session can be sold by ticket to people who are not members, and a post can simply be public. That gives you a way to charge someone who wants one thing without asking them to join, and a way to let a member skip a month without losing them.
Whether to offer an annual price at all is its own question, with real trade-offs on both sides; annual vs monthly membership pricing lays them out.
Setting up your tiers on Vibe
- Name the four rungs in your own wordsUse the sentence test from above. If two tiers would produce the same sentence, merge them.
- Set a price and inclusions for eachA Vibe holds up to four tiers, each with its own price and its own inclusions. Decide which tiers include live sessions and which include direct messages.
- Cap the top tierPick a seat count you can serve in the hours you have, and say the number in the tier's inclusions so members know it is limited.
- Put something on the wall before you openA few members-only posts and one file so that the first person to join finds a room, not an empty hall.
- Open the room and send one linkSupporters pick a tier on your page and pay by card. The charge lands on your own Stripe account, and Vibe keeps none of it. You can also accept bitcoin over Lightning.
The plan you are on is set by how many supporters the Vibe holds, never by what they pay you: Free up to 49 supporters, then Build at $25 a month from 50, Grow at $125 from 200, Scale at $325 from 1,000 and Thrive at $999 from 5,000. Any month in which your supporters pay you less than $500 costs $0, on every plan. If you are still working out whether to charge at all, start with how to start a paid community.
Questions
How many membership tiers should I have?
Three or four. Fewer than three leaves no room for a supporter who wants to spend more; more than four splits the same value too thin and makes the choice harder. Vibe holds up to four tiers per community.
What should the cheapest tier include?
Enough to feel like membership and not a tip: members-only posts, early access to public work, and the community itself. It exists to turn a follower into a member, not to make money.
What is a capped tier?
A tier with a seat limit members can see, for example ten seats. It suits anything that only works small, such as critique of a member's own work or a small live room. On Vibe any tier can be capped.
Does the platform fee change what I should charge?
Yes. On a platform that keeps a share of earnings, a $10 tier pays you less than $10 before processing; Patreon's pricing page states 10% plus processing and payout fees. On Vibe the tier price is charged on your own Stripe account and Vibe takes 0%.
Can I sell one item without a membership?
On Vibe, yes. A wall item can be sold on its own and a live session can be sold by ticket, to members and non-members alike.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-23