Start with the number Substack states
Short answer: On Substack you keep 90 cents of every paid-subscriber dollar, then card fees come off. At $2,500 a month that is $2,250 before card fees; a Vibe of the same income on the Grow plan keeps $2,375.
The formula is Kept = Subscription revenue × 0.90, minus card fees. Substack's about page adds that it is free to start and free to leave, with no platform fees or tiers until a writer earns money, so nothing is deducted from a free newsletter. The card fee is not printed as a number on that page, which is why this calculator stops before it. The same is true for Vibe: card processing runs on your own Stripe account at Stripe's rates, so neither column below includes it.
Four monthly totals, side by side
To compare with Vibe, dollars have to become supporters, because Vibe's plan is priced by how many people are in your community and never by revenue. At a typical newsletter price of $10 a month, $500 is 50 subscribers, $1,000 is 100, $2,500 is 250 and $5,000 is 500. On Vibe, 50 to 199 supporters is the Build plan at $25 a month and 200 to 999 is Grow at $125. One more rule shapes the first row: no plan fee is owed for any month in which your supporters pay you less than $500, and at exactly $500 the fee applies.
| Subscribers pay per month | Substack's 10% | You keep on Substack | Vibe plan at $10 a head | You keep on Vibe |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $500 | $50 | $450 | Build, $25 (50 supporters) | $475 |
| $1,000 | $100 | $900 | Build, $25 (100) | $975 |
| $2,500 | $250 | $2,250 | Grow, $125 (250) | $2,375 |
| $5,000 | $500 | $4,500 | Grow, $125 (500) | $4,875 |
Card fees are excluded from both columns; taxes are yours on either. A $5 newsletter doubles the supporter counts, which moves the $5,000 row to 1,000 supporters and the Scale plan at $325: still $4,675 kept against $4,500.
Per $100, and why the gap widens
A percentage scales with you; a plan steps up only when the room gets bigger. Between 200 and 999 supporters, Vibe's fee is $125 whether those people pay $5 or $50 a month, while Substack's share rises with every price increase you make. To see the effect at your own numbers, the homepage calculator takes a supporter count and a tier price and shows both results; the earnings calculator guide explains the method and lists every platform it covers.
When Substack's 10% is the right deal
If your work is a written newsletter and Substack is where your readers already are, its 10% is buying a home they know, and that can be worth more than the difference in the table. If your readers already know you and what you run is closer to a community, the percentage is buying less each month.
Substack's pricing rewards small and free newsletters: nothing is owed until someone pays, and there are no tiers of platform fees to climb. It is built for writing delivered by email, and if that is the whole product, the case for moving is thin. A Vibe is a different shape: a wall for posts, photos and video, up to four membership tiers, live sessions with chat beside the work for members, and automated emails under your name, with every member's email exportable to CSV in one click. Supporters pick a tier and pay by card, paid straight to you on your own Stripe account, and you can also accept bitcoin over Lightning.
The plain-language breakdown of Substack's charges is on what does Substack charge, and Vibe vs Substack covers the feature differences. Nothing on this page is a forecast of income; it only shows what each platform deducts from whatever you do earn.
Questions
Does Substack charge for free newsletters?
No. Its about page says it is free to start and free to leave, with no platform fees until a writer earns money. The 10% applies to paid subscription revenue.
Are card fees included in the 90% figure?
No. Substack states writers keep 90% of revenue minus credit card fees, so card fees are a further deduction. The card fee rate is not printed on the page we read, so this calculator leaves it out of both columns.
What does a Vibe cost if a month comes in under $500?
Nothing. Any month in which supporters pay you less than $500 costs $0 on every plan. At $500 or more, the plan fee for your supporter band is billed when the month ends.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Substack about checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-23