Vibe

Flat fee vs revenue share for creators

Creator platforms charge in one of three shapes: a share of what your members pay, a flat monthly plan, or a plan plus a smaller share. Each shape can be the cheapest one, depending on how many members you have and what they pay. This guide gives you the single formula that settles it, runs five different communities through it, and points out where a flat plan loses.

The short answer

Short answer: A revenue share is cheaper when your income is small or your members each pay very little, and a flat plan is cheaper once your members pay a meaningful price each month, because the plan stays put while the share keeps growing. To decide, divide the plan's price by what your members pay in a typical month; if that percentage is below the share, the flat plan wins.

The rest of this page is that one division, done carefully, with real prices from the platforms' own pages and processing left out on every side so the comparison stays fair.

3fee shapes: share, flat plan, plan plus share
1number decides it: the plan divided by a typical month
$3.25average price per supporter below which a 10% share beats Vibe's Scale plan at 1,000 supporters

One formula, three shapes

Write your typical month as R, what supporters pay you before processing. Then each shape costs:

  • Revenue share: rate times R. Patreon's pricing page states 10% of earnings, plus processing, currency conversion and payout fees.
  • Flat plan: the plan price, whatever R is. On Vibe the plan is set by supporter count and costs $0 in any month R is under $500.
  • Plan plus share: the plan price plus rate times R. Skool Pro is $99 a month plus a 2.9% transaction fee; Circle Professional is $89 a month, billed annually, plus 2%.

Divide any of these by R and you get the effective rate: the share of your income the platform really costs you that month. A share's effective rate never changes. A flat plan's effective rate falls every time R rises. That single difference is the whole debate.

A share

  • Costs nothing when you earn nothing
  • Costs the same fraction forever
  • Grows with every new member and every price rise

A flat plan

  • A known number you can budget for
  • Its fraction of your income shrinks as you grow
  • Can cost more than a share when members pay very little each

Five communities, worked through

Each row is a hypothetical community, not a forecast. Figures are platform fees only, before card processing, which every option passes on in some form.

CommunityR per month10% share (Patreon)Skool Pro ($99 + 2.9%)Circle Professional ($89 billed annually + 2%)Vibe
60 supporters at $8$480$48$112.92$98.60$0 (month under $500)
30 supporters at $40$1,200$120$133.80$113$0 (Free plan, under 50 supporters)
120 supporters at $12$1,440$144$140.76$117.80$25 (Build)
400 supporters at $15$6,000$600$273$209$125 (Grow)
1,000 supporters at $3$3,000$300$186$149$325 (Scale)

The last row is the one to notice. A thousand supporters paying $3 each put Vibe on its Scale plan at $325, which costs more than a 10% share and more than both plan-plus-share options. Flat plans sized by audience reward communities where each member pays a real price, and they are the wrong shape for a very large audience paying pocket change.

The break-even price per supporter

Because Vibe's plans are sized by supporter count, the fair comparison with a share is the average price per supporter. At the bottom of each band, this is the average monthly price at which a 10% share and the plan cost exactly the same:

Vibe planFromPlan per monthBreak-even average price vs a 10% share
Build50 supporters$25$5, but a month under $500 costs $0, so at Build a 10% share is never cheaper once the plan applies
Grow200 supporters$125$6.25
Scale1,000 supporters$325$3.25
Thrive5,000 supporters$999about $2

Above those prices the flat plan is cheaper, and the gap widens with every dollar. Higher in each band the break-even price drops further, because the same plan is spread over more supporters.

Watch out

Compare like with like. Leave processing out of every column, as here, or put it into every column. Adding it to one side only distorts the answer by a few percentage points.

Beyond the arithmetic

Cost is not the only difference between the shapes. A share aligns the platform's income with yours, which some creators like: the platform only earns when you do. A flat plan makes the platform's price predictable, which helps when you budget. On Vibe, the flat plan also comes with a structural difference: card payments are charged on your own Stripe account, Vibe never holds the money, and it takes 0% of every payment, so the plan is billed separately at the end of a month in which supporters paid you $500 or more, rather than deducted from each payment. A creator can also accept bitcoin over Lightning on the same terms.

The full table of what each platform charges is in creator platform fees, and the short definitions are in what a revenue share is and what a flat plan is. To run your own supporter count and price through these exact rates, use the earnings calculator.

Questions

Is a flat plan always cheaper than a revenue share?

No. It is cheaper once members pay a meaningful price each. A very large audience paying very little each, such as 1,000 supporters at $3, can pay less under a 10% share than under a flat plan sized by supporter count.

How do I compare a flat plan with a revenue share?

Divide the plan's monthly price by what your supporters pay you in a typical month. If the result is below the share's percentage, the flat plan costs less.

What does a plan plus a share cost?

Both parts, every month. Skool Pro is $99 a month plus 2.9%; Circle Professional is $89 a month, billed annually, plus 2%, per their pricing pages.

How is Vibe's plan priced?

By supporter count: Free up to 49, Build $25 from 50, Grow $125 from 200, Scale $325 from 1,000, Thrive $999 from 5,000. Any month in which supporters pay you less than $500 costs $0, and Vibe takes 0% of payments.

Keep the whole payment.

Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.

Sources

  1. Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
  2. Skool pricing checked 2026-09-23
  3. Circle pricing checked 2026-09-24

Last updated 2026-09-28