The short answer
Short answer: Usually yes, but not as the main product: include the replay for members on your working tier and sell it separately to everyone else at around half the ticket. Skip replays entirely only when the live room itself is the product, such as critique of each person's own work, where a recording would give away what the ticket pays for.
The fear behind the question is that a replay kills attendance. It can, when the replay is cheap, instant and identical to the live hour. It does not when the live session offers something the recording cannot: your answer to their question, their piece looked at, the goal reached together.
What a replay cannot give
- An answer to the viewer's own question
- Their work seen and corrected
- The room finishing together
What a replay does well
- Reaches the people in the wrong time zone
- Lets a student rewatch the hard two minutes
- Keeps selling after the session ends
Four replay models
| Model | How it works | Suits | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| No replay | The session exists only live | Critique rooms, small capped groups | People in other time zones cannot buy at all |
| Included for members | Members on the right tier can watch afterwards | A monthly session that gives a tier its value | Some members stop coming live |
| Sold on its own | Anyone can buy the recording as a single item | Popular one-off workshops | Priced too low, it undercuts the ticket |
| Included, plus sold | Members get it, non-members buy it | A community with both regulars and drop-ins | Needs a clear price gap between ticket and replay |
The fourth model is the one this page recommends for most teaching, because it gives members a reason to stay and gives strangers a way to buy after the fact.
Protecting live attendance
- Keep the live-only parts live. Questions answered by name, a look at someone's piece, the goal reached together. Say at the start that these do not happen in the recording.
- Post the replay a day or two later, not the same hour. Waiting a little keeps the live session feeling like the event.
- Tell people what they missed. A recap post that lists the questions asked live makes the next session more attractive than the recording.
- Keep the replay whole. Selling a trimmed highlight as the replay makes buyers feel short-changed.
Look at attendance across three sessions before and three after you start offering replays, not one. A single quiet session tells you nothing; a trend across several does.
Pricing a replay
Half the live ticket is a sensible starting point. Much less, and the replay tells people the live hour was overpriced; much more, and nobody buys a recording when they could have come. As an illustration only: a $40 live workshop with a $20 replay, and both included in a member tier priced below the cost of two tickets. For the ticket side, see how much to charge for an online workshop.
Two adjustments are worth making. A replay of a class that depends on following along in real time, such as a bake with proving times, is worth a little less, because the recording is harder to use. A replay of a dense technique demonstration is worth a little more, because people will pause and rewatch it for months. Keep the price the same across your catalogue once you have picked it, so buyers learn what a replay from you costs.
Where a replay sells, and what is kept
A replay is a video file: you record the session yourself, then upload the recording like any other video. Any platform that hosts or sells video can carry it. What differs is the share each keeps.
| Platform | What it states |
|---|---|
| Gumroad | Sells digital products and courses; 10% plus $0.50 per direct sale, 30% on sales through its Discover marketplace |
| Patreon | Hosts video; keeps 10% of earnings plus processing and payout fees |
| Vibe | Video on the wall can be public, members-only or sold on its own; 0% kept |
On Vibe, every video a member receives carries an invisible mark unique to that account, on every plan, so a leaked copy of a replay identifies the account it was delivered to.
Deciding, in five questions
- Is the live room the product?If the value is each person's work being seen, do not sell a replay.
- Where do your members live?If many are in other time zones, a replay is how they take part at all.
- Which tier should include it?The working tier, so the replay becomes a reason to stay a member.
- What is the ticket?Set the replay near half of it.
- How will you check attendance?Compare several sessions before and after, then adjust.
The full picture of tickets, tiers and replays sits in the online workshops guide, and running the live hour well enough that people want to be there is in how to run a live workshop online.
Questions
Do replays reduce live attendance?
They can, when the replay is cheap, immediate and gives the same experience. Keeping questions, critique and the shared goal live, and posting the replay a day or two later, protects attendance.
How much should a class replay cost?
Around half the live ticket is a sensible starting point, with the replay included for members on your working tier.
Can I sell a single video to non-members on Vibe?
Yes. Anything on the wall can be public, members-only or sold on its own, and Vibe keeps 0% of the sale.
What stops a buyer sharing the replay?
Nothing stops sharing entirely. On Vibe every video a member receives carries an invisible mark unique to that account, so a leaked copy identifies the account it came from.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Gumroad pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Gumroad pricing (products) checked 2026-09-24
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-28