The short answer
Short answer: Fourthwall takes a 5% flat fee on memberships and on digital products on its free plan, plus 2.9% and 30 cents processing on US card transactions; its Pro plan at $15 a month removes the digital product fee, and the page does not say it removes the membership fee. Vibe takes 0% of what supporters pay and charges a flat plan that stays at $0 in any month under $500.
Fourthwall's numbers come from its pricing page, fetched on the date shown under Sources. Its physical products carry no percentage; product costs are deducted from the sale price instead, which is a different model from anything Vibe offers and is not compared here.
The fee table
| Fourthwall | Vibe | |
|---|---|---|
| Memberships | 5% flat fee | 0% |
| Digital products | 5% on the free plan; 0% on Pro at $15 a month | 0% on files and video sold from the wall |
| Physical products | No percentage; product costs deducted | Not offered |
| Card processing | 2.9% + 30 cents on US card transactions | Stripe's rate, on your own Stripe account |
| Monthly plan | Free, or Pro at $15 | $0 up to 49 supporters; $25, $125, $325, $999 by community size, and $0 in any month under $500 |
| Who is the merchant | Not stated on the pricing page | You. Vibe never holds the money. |
Shop or room
The real difference between these two is not the percentage; it is what the supporter is paying for. Fourthwall's centre of gravity is the storefront. A creator with an audience elsewhere sends people to a shop, they buy a hoodie or a download, and a membership is one more thing on the shelf. That is a good fit for a channel whose fans want something to hold.
A Vibe's centre of gravity is the room. Supporters pick a tier and pay by card to be inside: to read the wall, watch the live sessions, get the files, message you where the tier includes it. Up to four tiers can carry their own price, and a tier can be capped at a set number of seats. Live sessions happen inside the Vibe for its members, with chat beside the work and a goal the room can see, and a one-off session can sell tickets. Every photo and video a member receives carries an invisible mark unique to that account, so a leaked file points back to the account it was delivered to.
Fourthwall's shape
- Shop with merch and downloads
- Membership as one product among others
- 5% kept on memberships
Vibe's shape
- Wall, tiers, live sessions, DMs
- Files and video sellable from the wall
- 0% kept, plan by headcount
A creator's month on each
Take a creator with 120 members paying $8 each, so $960 a month, and two digital downloads a month at $20 each to non-members. On Fourthwall's free plan the platform keeps $48 from memberships and $2 from the downloads, before processing. On Pro at $15 the downloads carry no fee, so the month is $48 plus $15. On Vibe the same creator is on Build at $25, the platform keeps nothing from the memberships or the files, and processing is Stripe's on the creator's own account.
Leaving with your people
On Vibe, every member's email exports to CSV in one click, any day, and the emails Vibe sends on your behalf go out under your name, so members know you rather than the platform. Whether Fourthwall exports member emails was not stated on the page we read, so this page makes no claim about it; check inside your account before you plan a move. The general method for moving a community without losing it is in Own your audience.
When Fourthwall is the better choice
Fourthwall wins if merch is a real part of your income and you want the shop and the membership under one roof. Vibe wins if your supporters pay to be in the room with you and you want the platform to take nothing from that.
Fourthwall's physical product side is something Vibe simply does not do: printed goods, fulfilment, a storefront that looks like a shop. A creator whose audience buys hoodies and posters will get more from Fourthwall than from any community platform, and the 5% on memberships is a small line next to merch margins. Its free plan also means there is no bill at all until something sells.
The case for Vibe is the one for any creator whose value is presence rather than product. If your members are there for the live sessions, the wall and the conversation, 5% of every membership payment forever is a fee for something Fourthwall is not really built around, and Vibe's flat plan, at $0 in any month under $500 and never a share, is the cheaper fit. More options are laid out on Fourthwall alternatives, and every platform's verified rates are together on the comparison hub.
Questions
What does Fourthwall charge on memberships?
Its pricing page states a 5% flat fee on memberships, plus 2.9% and 30 cents payment processing on US card transactions. The Pro plan at $15 a month removes the fee on digital products; the page does not say it removes the membership fee.
Does Vibe sell merch?
No. Vibe is a community around a craft: a wall, up to four tiers, live sessions for members, tickets, DMs and automated emails. Files and video can be sold from the wall; physical goods are not part of it.
What does Vibe take from a membership payment?
Nothing. The card charge is made on the creator's own Stripe account and Vibe takes 0%. The creator pays a flat plan by community size, and only for months in which supporters paid them $500 or more.
Can I run both?
Nothing stops a creator from keeping a Fourthwall shop for merch and running the community itself as a Vibe. The member list on Vibe exports to CSV any day, so the two can share an audience.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Fourthwall pricing checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-23