The short answer
Short answer: If your membership is a community around a craft, the platforms that take a percentage cost you more every month you grow, and the ones that charge a flat plan cost you less the bigger you get. Patreon takes 10% plus processing. Vibe takes 0% and charges a flat plan that costs nothing until your supporters pay you $500 in a month.
Every number on this page comes from the platform's own pricing page, fetched on the date shown under Sources. Where a platform does not publish a number, this page does not invent one.
What Patreon actually charges
Patreon's pricing page states the fee plainly: 10% of the income you earn on Patreon, plus payment processing, currency conversion, payout fees and applicable taxes. It is free to start, so nothing is owed before the first member pays; from then on the platform's share comes off the top of every payment.
For that, Patreon gives a mature product: monthly and annual subscriptions, multiple tiers, one-time payments, hosting for audio, images, text, video and livestreams, email newsletters, chats, DMs and comments, member analytics, free trials, discounts and sales, and podcast tools. It also handles chargebacks, disputes and fraud on the creator's behalf, which matters more than it sounds if you have never dealt with a dispute yourself.
A creator whose members pay $2,000 a month hands Patreon about $200 of it, every month, before processing. At $5,000 a month it is $500. The fee never plateaus, because it is a share, not a plan.
The alternatives, by how they charge
There are three ways a membership platform gets paid, and knowing which one you are looking at tells you most of what you need to know.
A share of what you earn
Patreon (10%), Substack (writers keep 90% of revenue minus card fees), Ko-fi (5% on memberships, shop sales and commissions on its free plan, 0% on simple tips) and Gumroad (10% plus $0.50 per direct sale, 30% through its Discover marketplace) all take a percentage. Nothing to pay up front, and the cost grows with you.
A monthly plan plus a smaller share
Memberful is $49 a month plus a 4.9% transaction fee. Circle's plans run $89 a month with a 2% fee, $199 with 1%, and custom pricing with 0.5%. Mighty Networks runs $79 a month with 2%, $179 with 1%, $354 with 0.5%. Skool is $9 a month with a 10% fee, or $99 a month with 2.9%. Podia's entry plan is $42 a month with 5%, and its higher plans drop the fee. Teachable's Starter plan is $39 a month with a 7.5% fee; its Builder and Growth plans charge 0% but cost $89 and $189 a month.
A flat plan and nothing else
Kajabi charges no revenue share but starts at $179 a month. Vibe charges a flat plan sized by how many supporters your community holds, takes 0% of what they pay, and charges nothing at all for any month in which your supporters pay you less than $500.
| Platform | What it takes | Monthly plan |
|---|---|---|
| Patreon | 10% + processing | none |
| Substack | 10% (writers keep 90%) + card fees | none |
| Ko-fi | 5% on memberships and shop, 0% on simple tips | none (Gold removes the fee for a fixed price) |
| Gumroad | 10% + $0.50 per direct sale | none |
| Memberful | 4.9% | $49 |
| Circle | 2% / 1% / 0.5% | $89 / $199 / custom |
| Mighty Networks | 2% / 1% / 0.5% | $79 / $179 / $354 |
| Skool | 10% / 2.9% | $9 / $99 |
| Kajabi | 0% (processing only) | $179 / $249 / $499 |
| Vibe | 0% | $0 until $500 a month from supporters; then $25 to $999 by community size |
What you keep out of every $100
Percentages are abstract. Here is the same comparison on a $100 payment from a member, before your own taxes and before card processing, which every platform passes on in one form or another.
The bar for Vibe is the whole bar because the plan is paid separately, as rent. Whether that rent is cheaper than a share depends on your numbers: run yours on the calculator, which uses the same verified rates.
How a Vibe membership works
A Vibe is a creator's community around a craft: cooking, knitting, gaming, woodworking, photography, fitness, music, and the rest. It runs the same kind of tiered membership you know from Patreon, with a few differences that matter every month.
- Up to four tiers, each with its own price and inclusions. A tier can be capped, for example ten seats for critiques of members' own work.
- A wall for posts, photos, video and files: public, members only, or sold on their own.
- Live sessions for members, with chat beside the work and a goal the room can see. Tickets for one-off classes. The recording lands on the wall for whoever missed it.
- Direct messages where the tier includes them, and automated emails under your name: welcome notes, renewal reminders at 7, 3 and 1 days, win-back notes, premiere announcements.
- Every member's email exports to CSV in one click, any day.
Supporters pick a tier on your Vibe page and pay by card. The charge is made on your own Stripe account, so the money never passes through Vibe and Vibe takes none of it. You can also accept bitcoin over Lightning, for supporters who prefer it or who live where Stripe does not operate. Memberships renew monthly, and a member can cancel from your page at any time.
On a revenue-share platform
- A share of every payment, forever
- The platform is the merchant; payouts run on its calendar
- Growing costs you more each month
On Vibe
- 0% of what your supporters pay
- Charges land on your own Stripe account
- A flat plan, $0 until $500 a month from supporters
Vibe's plans, in numbers
The plan is decided by how many supporters your community holds, never by what it earns. Free covers up to 49 supporters, with 5 GB of photos and video and 100 live viewer-hours a month. Build is $25 a month from 50 supporters, with 50 GB and 500 viewer-hours. Grow is $125 from 200 supporters, with 250 GB and 2,000 viewer-hours. Scale is $325 from 1,000 supporters, and Thrive is $999 from 5,000. A viewer-hour is one person watching for one hour, so 500 of them is a hundred people at five hour-long sessions.
Whatever the band, a month in which your supporters pay you less than $500 costs $0. Reach $500 in a month and that month's plan fee applies, billed when the month ends. Extras are opt-in only: 1 TB of extra storage for $125 a month on any paid plan, and extra viewer-hours at $25 per 1,000 at 720p30 or $125 per 1,000 at 1080p60. Nothing is charged without you switching it on.
Opening a Vibe
- Sign up with an emailThere is no identity check and no fee to start.
- Put a card on fileIt is never charged. It exists so that bot farms cannot open accounts by the hundred and so that a person removed for prohibited content stays out. Vibe keeps a fingerprint of the card, never the number.
- Connect StripeA few minutes on Stripe's own pages; the account is yours. Prefer bitcoin, or in a country Stripe does not serve? Connect a Lightning wallet instead, or as well.
- Open the roomName your tiers, write the first post, send one link. Members pick a tier on your page and pay.
Moving your members over
Nobody moves a community in an afternoon, and the creators who do it well run both places for a while. Announce the move to your members with the reason and the date, open the new tiers at the same prices or slightly better, and give people a month to follow you before you close the old one. A welcome email on the new platform, sent under your name, does most of the work. The longer version is in Own your audience, and the week-by-week plan is in Moving from Patreon.
When Patreon is still the right choice
Stay on Patreon if your income depends on the tools only it has, and move if the 10% has become your biggest monthly cost.
Patreon's podcast tools, its native video and livestream hosting under one roof, and the fact that it handles chargebacks and disputes for you are real advantages, and a creator whose whole workflow runs through them has good reason to stay. It also has years of member habits behind it: some supporters already have an account and a card there, which makes the first payment easier.
The case for leaving is arithmetic, not sentiment. Once your community pays you a few thousand dollars a month, 10% of it is a serious bill, and it never goes down. A flat plan does. If that is where you are, the calculator will tell you in thirty seconds what the difference is for your numbers.
Questions
How much does Patreon take?
Patreon's pricing page states 10% of the income a creator earns on Patreon, plus payment processing, currency conversion, payout fees and applicable taxes.
Does Vibe take a cut of memberships or tips?
No. Supporter payments are charged on the creator's own Stripe account, or paid over Lightning to the creator's own wallet. Vibe takes 0% and charges a flat plan instead, which costs nothing until supporters pay the creator $500 in a month.
Do my members need bitcoin to pay on Vibe?
No. Members pay by card. Lightning is an option a creator can switch on for supporters who prefer it or who live where Stripe does not operate.
Can I export my member list?
On Vibe, every member's email exports to CSV in one click, any day. Whether and how Patreon exports patron data was not verified for this page; check your account's export options before you announce a move.
Is there a free plan?
Vibe's Free plan covers up to 49 supporters. On every plan, a month in which your supporters pay you less than $500 costs $0.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Substack about checked 2026-09-23
- Ko-fi Gold and fees checked 2026-09-23
- Gumroad pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Memberful pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Circle pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Mighty Networks pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Skool pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Podia pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Teachable pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Kajabi pricing checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-23