Vibe

Moving from Patreon: a week-by-week plan

The hardest part of leaving Patreon is not the data, once you have checked your account's export options and pulled the list. It is the month in which some patrons have followed you and some have not. This guide is a five-week plan for that month, worked through with an illustrator who runs a members-only sketchbook, and it is honest about what Patreon does that you will have to replace.

The short answer

Short answer: Export your patron emails first, open the new tiers at the same prices, announce the move once with a date, then keep Patreon open for four more weeks while people follow you. Close it only when the last renewal cycle has passed.

The order matters. Creators who announce before the new room exists send people to a door that is not open yet, and creators who close Patreon on announcement day lose everyone who was going to read the email next week. The plan below puts the export and the new room in place before a single patron hears about it.

5 weeksfrom export to closing the old page
1announcement, then reminders, never a campaign
10%of earnings that stops leaving the month you close, per Patreon's pricing page

What you can take with you

Start by checking your account's export options for the list of people who pay you; Patreon's pricing page, the one we read, does not describe the export itself, so this guide will not either. Whatever the export gives you, at minimum you want the email address and the tier each patron is on, because the tier is what tells you which door to point them at on the new platform.

What does not come with you is the payment relationship. Patreon is the merchant for those charges, and the card each patron entered there stays there. Every one of them will pick a tier again and pay again on the new page. That is the whole reason the plan runs for weeks instead of days.

Tip

Download the export twice: once on the day you start planning and once on announcement day. People join and leave in between, and the second file is the one you will actually work from.

The five-week plan

Our worked example is an illustrator with 140 patrons across three tiers: $3 for the sketchbook feed, $8 for process videos, and $25 for a monthly critique of members' own work, capped at fifteen seats. The plan assumes Patreon renews each patron on the date they joined, which is why nothing closes before week five.

  1. Week 1: export and build the empty roomDownload the patron list. Open the new Vibe with the same three tiers at the same three prices and the same cap on the critique tier. Put the last month of sketchbook posts on the wall, members-only, so the room is not bare on the day people arrive. Connect Stripe so the first payment can happen the moment someone follows.
  2. Week 2: tell the top tier firstSend a private note to the fifteen critique members before the public announcement. They pay the most, they know you best, and if a few of them are already inside when the rest arrive the room looks alive. Fix anything they trip over.
  3. Week 3: announce oncePost the announcement on Patreon and email the exported list the same morning. Say why you are moving, the date the old page closes, and that prices are unchanged. One link, straight to the tier page. The welcome email on the new platform goes out under your name the moment someone joins, so you do not write that one by hand.
  4. Week 4: reminders, not pressureTwo reminders, a week apart, to the people on the export who have not appeared on the new list yet. Compare the two CSV files to find them. Post the week's sketchbook pages in both places so nobody feels punished for being slow.
  5. Week 5: close on the far side of the last renewalBy now every patron has been charged once more on Patreon and has had the choice to follow. Post a final note with the new link, stop the Patreon page, and move the archive across for the members who asked for it.

Mapping the tiers

Keep the prices identical. A move is already one change; a price rise on top of it gives people two reasons to think instead of one. If a tier needs restructuring, do it two months after the move when everyone has settled.

On PatreonOn the VibeWhat changes for the member
$3 sketchbook$3 tier, wall accessNothing but the URL
$8 process videos$8 tier, wall plus video postsVideo lands on the wall instead of a feed
$25 monthly critique, 15 seats$25 capped tier, 15 seats, live sessionThe critique becomes a live session with chat beside the work

A member pays by picking a tier on your page and entering a card; the charge is made on your own Stripe account, and Vibe takes none of it. You can also accept bitcoin over Lightning for the few who prefer it. Memberships renew monthly, reminders go out at 7, 3 and 1 days, and anyone can cancel from your page. The announcement wording is in how to announce a platform move, and the wider ownership argument is in Own your audience.

What you lose by leaving Patreon

Patreon's pricing page lists things a Vibe does not do, and pretending otherwise would cost you members later. It lists podcast tools, annual subscriptions, free trials, discounts and sales, and member analytics; if your membership is a podcast, or annual billing and trials are how you sell it, those are real reasons to stay. Patreon is also the merchant for every charge made there, so whatever it handles on your behalf around payments (check its pricing page for the current list) becomes yours on a Vibe, where the charges sit on your own Stripe account: more control and more responsibility in the same breath. And a Vibe has no discovery feed, so the people who find you will be the ones you bring.

Gone after the move

  • Podcast tools
  • Annual billing, free trials, discounts and sales
  • Being inside a large platform
  • Patrons who already had a card on file there

Gained after the move

  • 0% taken from what members pay
  • Charges on your own Stripe account
  • Every member's email in a CSV, any day
  • A flat plan that is $0 in any month under $500

If the podcast tools are load-bearing for you, read the Patreon alternatives page before committing; it says plainly when staying is right.

What the move does to the arithmetic

Vibe$100
Patreon$90
Out of $100 a member pays, before processing and taxes. Patreon's 10% is from its pricing page, fetched 2026-09-23 (see Sources). Vibe's plan fee is paid separately and is not in the bar.

The illustrator's 140 patrons pay about $1,100 a month. On Patreon roughly $110 of it leaves before processing. On a Vibe of 140 supporters the plan is Build at $25 a month, and it is owed only in months that reach $500 from supporters, which this one does. The difference is about $85 a month at today's size and grows with every new member, because one number is a share and the other is rent. Run your own figures before you decide; a smaller community may find the gap too small to bother with, and that is a fair conclusion.

Questions

Can I export my Patreon patrons?

The Patreon pricing page we read does not describe exports, so check your account's export options for what is available and which fields come with it; you want the email and the tier at minimum.

Do my patrons have to pay again on the new platform?

Yes. Patreon holds the card details for charges made there. On a Vibe each member picks a tier and pays by card on your own Stripe account, which is why the plan keeps both rooms open for a month.

Should I raise prices when I move?

Not on the same day. Keep tiers identical through the move and revisit pricing two months later, once the membership has settled in the new room.

What does Vibe charge during the move?

Vibe takes 0% of what members pay. The plan is sized by supporter count and costs $0 in any month in which supporters pay you less than $500; at $500 or more the month's plan fee applies, billed when the month ends.

Keep the whole payment.

Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.

Sources

  1. Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23

Last updated 2026-09-24