Answer first
Short answer: Patreon costs less while members pay you under about $1,113 a month; above that, Circle Professional, at $89 a month billed annually plus a 2% transaction fee, leaves you more. Decide on the shape of the community as well: Patreon for a creator's feed of work, Circle for a place where members talk to one another.
Circle quotes every plan in USD on an annual-billing basis, with no month-to-month figure beside it, so read each Circle number here as the monthly rate of a yearly plan. Card processing is left out on both sides, because neither rate was on the pages we could read.
One rate against four plans
| Patreon | Circle Professional | Circle Business | Circle Scale | Circle Plus | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plan price | None | $89/mo | $199/mo | $419/mo | Custom |
| Share of each payment | 10% | 2% | 1% | 1% | 0.5% |
| Admins | Not stated | 3 | 5 | 10 | Not stated |
| Spaces | Not stated | 20 | 30 | 100 | Not stated |
| Members | No cap on the pricing page | Unlimited | Unlimited | Unlimited | Unlimited |
| Getting started | Free to start, no monthly fee | 14-day trial, no card | 14-day trial, no card | 14-day trial, no card | 14-day trial, no card |
A full year at Circle's rates comes to $1,068 on Professional, $2,388 on Business and $5,028 on Scale, before the transaction fee. Because the page quotes annual billing only, that yearly figure is the honest entry price to plan for, and it is worth knowing before the trial runs out.
Where the lines cross
Patreon's cost is a straight 10%. Each Circle plan is a fixed amount plus a smaller slope, so each one overtakes Patreon at a different revenue level.
Inside Circle, stepping up from Professional to Business only pays for itself on fees above $11,000 a month, where 1 point of revenue covers the $110 difference. Scale charges the same 1% as Business. Below that line, move up for the extra admins and spaces, never for the lower rate.
Every platform's rate sits in one table on creator platform fees, and the line-by-line Circle numbers are on Circle fees.
Who is in the room
Patreon's pricing page reads like a creator's toolkit: monthly and annual subscriptions, several tiers, one-time payments, hosting for audio, images, text, video and livestreams, newsletters, chats, DMs and comments, member analytics, free trials, discounts and podcast tools. Nearly everything on it points back at the person being supported.
Circle's page reads like a venue: community, courses, live events, a website, a member directory, gamification, a custom domain, and iOS, Android and desktop apps, on every plan. Members find and follow each other there, and the host sets up the rooms.
- If members mostly comment on what you post, Patreon's shape fits.
- If they would keep talking during a week you were away, Circle's does.
- If you teach in modules and host events, Circle lists courses and live events on every plan.
- If you record episodes or video, Patreon lists podcast tools and media hosting.
When Patreon is the better choice
Patreon wins below roughly $1,100 a month, where its tenth is the smaller bill and there is no yearly plan to commit to. It also wins for a creator whose supporters pay for the creator's own work: a podcast feed, video, livestreams, posts on a schedule and a chat with you. None of that asks you to design spaces, run a directory or keep a forum civil. For a creator who would rather make things than moderate a town square, that is worth the higher percentage.
When Circle is the better choice
Patreon for a creator-led membership that is still small or built on media. Circle for a peer community with courses and events, once revenue has cleared the crossing point and you are ready to pay for a year.
Circle is the better choice when the conversation between members is what they pay for. Unlimited members, dedicated spaces, a directory, courses, live events and native apps are what a professional network or cohort program needs. Its transaction fee is a fifth or a tenth of Patreon's rate, so at $3,000 a month Professional costs about $149 against Patreon's $300. If that is your reason to leave, Moving from Patreon has the week-by-week plan.
A plan with no share at all
One more model is worth a look if you like Circle's rent-for-the-room pricing but not the transaction fee on top. Vibe takes 0% of what supporters pay and bills a flat plan by community size, from $0 for up to 49 supporters to $25, $125, $325 or $999 a month. A month in which supporters pay you less than $500 costs nothing, and each month is judged on its own. A Vibe is a community around a craft, with a wall, up to four tiers and live sessions for members.
The full head-to-head is on Vibe vs Circle.
Questions
Is Circle billed monthly or yearly?
Yearly, as far as its pricing page shows. The listed rates (Professional $89 a month, Business $199, Scale $419, Circle Plus custom) are on the annual-billing basis, and no month-to-month price appears beside them.
What transaction fee does Circle charge?
2% on Professional, 1% on Business and Scale, and 0.5% on Circle Plus, on top of the plan price, per its pricing page.
At what revenue does Circle beat Patreon on cost?
Circle Professional ($89 a month billed annually, plus 2%) matches Patreon's 10% at about $1,113 a month in member revenue and costs less above it. Processing is left out of both.
Does Patreon have a monthly fee?
No. Its pricing page says Patreon is free to start; it keeps 10% of what you earn there, with processing, currency conversion, payout fees and taxes on top.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Circle pricing (plans and transaction fees) checked 2026-09-23
- Circle pricing (annual billing, Scale plan, trial, admins, spaces, features) checked 2026-09-24
Last updated 2026-09-26