Vibe

Cette page n’est pas encore traduite. Elle est affichée en anglais.

Vibe vs Substack

Substack is a publishing tool with a paywall attached: you write, readers subscribe, Substack keeps a tenth. Vibe is a community room with a membership attached: you teach or share a craft, members pay a tier, and Vibe keeps nothing from the payment. They overlap on paid subscriptions and on almost nothing else, which is why the right pick depends on what you actually do all week.

The answer in two sentences

Short answer: Substack takes 10% of paid subscription revenue (its about page says writers keep 90%, minus credit card fees) and is built around a written newsletter. Vibe takes 0%, charges a flat plan that costs $0 until supporters pay you $500 in a month, and is built around a community with a wall, tiers and live sessions.

If your work is an essay a week, Substack is the obvious home for it. If your work is a craft your members want to learn, watch and practise alongside you, a newsletter is a thin container for it. The sections below put the two on the same table using only what Substack publishes on its own about page, fetched 2026-09-23.

Substack's model

  • Free to start and free to leave
  • No platform fee until a writer earns money
  • Writers keep 90% of revenue, minus card fees
  • The share applies for as long as you charge

Vibe's model

  • Free to start, no identity check
  • 0% of supporter payments, ever
  • A flat plan sized by supporter count
  • $0 for any month under $500 from supporters

What Substack states about its fee

Substack's about page is direct: it is free to start and free to leave, there are no platform fees or tiers until a writer earns money, and once they do, writers keep 90% of their revenue minus credit card fees. In other words the platform's income is a tenth of yours, taken from every paid subscription, and card processing is deducted on top of that.

That is a fair deal for a writer who might never charge, because a free newsletter costs nothing. It becomes an expensive deal for a writer with a paying audience, because 10% of a growing number is a growing number. There is no plan you can switch to that makes the share go away.

Vibe$100
Substack$90
Out of $100 a subscriber pays, before card fees and taxes. Substack's share from its about page, fetched 2026-09-23 (see Sources). Vibe's plan is a separate flat fee, not in the bar.

Verified comparison table

ItemVibeSubstack
Platform's share of payments0%10% (writers keep 90%)
Card feesStripe's, on your own accountDeducted from the writer's 90%
Cost before you earn$0$0
Recurring plan$25 to $999 a month by supporter count, waived under $500 a monthNone
Merchant of recordYou, via your own Stripe accountNot stated on the page we read
FormatWall (posts, photos, video, files), live sessions, tickets, DMsNewsletters, podcasts, video, live video, subscriber chat, comment threads
TiersUp to four, cappableNot stated on the page we read
LeavingCSV of every member's email, any dayFree to leave
BitcoinOptional, over LightningNot stated

Substack's about page names its formats and its revenue split but does not describe tiers, the merchant of record or exports, so those cells say so rather than guess. If you need those specifics, read Substack's own help pages, which this site could not fetch.

Different in kind, not just in price

The fee is the headline, but the deeper difference is what each platform is for. Substack's about page describes a publishing home for writers and creators: newsletters first, with podcasts, video, live video, subscriber chat and comment threads around them. Its unit of work is still a post that lands in an inbox, and that is exactly right for commentary, reporting, serialised fiction and analysis.

A Vibe is a room. Its unit of work is whatever your craft produces: a knitting pattern with a video walkthrough, a woodworking session where members watch the joint being cut and ask questions in the chat beside it, a fitness block with a capped tier for people who want their form checked. The wall holds posts, photos, video and files, each one public, members only or sold on its own. Live sessions run inside the Vibe for members, with a goal the room can see, and one-off sessions can be ticketed. Emails go out under your name for welcomes, renewals, win-backs and premieres, so the newsletter job is still done, just not as the centre of the thing.

A useful test

If you could deliver everything you sell as an email, Substack is enough and its 10% may be worth paying for the simplicity. If your members would ask where the video, the live session or the file is, you are describing a community, and a community is what Vibe charges rent for.

What the flat plan costs

Vibe's plans are sized by how many supporters the community holds, never by revenue. Free covers up to 49 supporters, with 5 GB of media and 100 live viewer-hours a month. Build is $25 a month from 50 supporters, with 50 GB and 500 viewer-hours. Grow is $125 from 200 supporters with 250 GB and 2,000 viewer-hours. Scale is $325 from 1,000 and Thrive is $999 from 5,000. A viewer-hour is one person watching for one hour.

Nothing is owed until your supporters pay you $500 in a month. A month under that costs $0; a month at or above it is billed at that month's plan rate when the month ends. Extras, such as 1 TB of storage for $125 a month, are switched on by you or not charged at all.

$25a month on Build, from 50 supporters
$0in any month supporters pay you under $500
100%of each card payment lands on your own Stripe account

Where the flat plan overtakes a 10% share is a simple line to draw for your own audience; the calculator draws it.

When Substack is the better choice

Verdict

Pick Substack if you are a writer first and the product is the writing: an inbox is the right delivery, and a 10% share on a modest paid list is a small price for not thinking about tools. Pick Vibe if the product is a craft and the people around it, or if your paid audience has grown to where a tenth of it is a serious monthly bill.

Substack is excellent at the thing it does. Free readers cost nothing, the writing tool is the centre of the interface, podcasts and live video are on the menu, and the fee only starts when money does. A writer whose audience reads and listens rather than practises gains little from Vibe's capped tiers and marked media and would be paying a flat plan for rooms they do not use.

Vibe is the better fit when the membership is about doing something together rather than reading something alone. It is also the better fit when you want to be the merchant: card payments are charged on your own Stripe account and Vibe never holds the money. For a broader view of the field, the Substack alternatives page covers other platforms with their verified numbers, and the comparison hub lists every pairing on this site.

Questions

How much does Substack take?

Substack's about page says writers keep 90% of their revenue minus credit card fees, that it is free to start and free to leave, and that there are no platform fees until a writer earns money.

Does Vibe send emails like a newsletter?

Vibe sends automated emails under your name: welcome notes, renewal reminders at 7, 3 and 1 days, win-back notes and premiere announcements. It is a community platform with email attached rather than a newsletter tool.

Can I keep a free Substack and run a paid Vibe?

Yes. Many creators keep a free newsletter for reach and run the paid community elsewhere. Vibe places no restriction on that.

Do I pay Vibe if nobody subscribes?

No. A month in which supporters pay you less than $500 costs $0, on every plan.

Keep the whole payment.

Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.

Sources

  1. Substack about checked 2026-09-23

Last updated 2026-09-23