The short answer
Short answer: Anchor your main tier to the price of one thing members already buy from you, such as a pattern, a plan or a class ticket, and set it so a member gets at least that much value every month. Build the cheaper and dearer tiers around it, subtract what your platform keeps, and hold the price for 60 days before you judge it.
The mistake is pricing from the cost of making the content. Members do not pay for your hours; they pay for what the month does for them. Your hours only set the price of the tiers that include your personal time.
Six steps to a price
- List what a member gets in a monthPosts, files, live sessions, replies. Be literal; if it does not happen every month, leave it off.
- Find your anchorThe price of one thing people already buy from you, or from someone like you: a single pattern, a preset pack, a workshop ticket.
- Set the main tier near the anchorA member should feel they get at least one anchor's worth each month. If a pattern sells for $8, a $10 tier with every new pattern is easy to accept.
- Place the other tiersA cheap tier for people who only want to support you, and one or two higher tiers priced by the time of yours they include. The shape is in membership tiers and pricing.
- Subtract the platformWork out what reaches you after the platform's share and plan. The difference between platforms can be larger than the difference between two prices you are choosing between.
- Test it for 60 daysWatch how many join and how many renew, over the whole window, before changing anything.
A worked example: a knitting designer
The figures below are illustrative, chosen to show the method, not a forecast of what any community will earn. The designer's single patterns sell for $7, so the main tier sits just above that.
| Tier | Price | What is in it | Members | Monthly |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Supporter | $5 | Members-only posts and the community | 40 | $200 |
| Pattern Club | $12 | Every new pattern as a file, plus the archive | 30 | $360 |
| Knit-along | $25 | Pattern Club plus a monthly live session with chat | 8 | $200 |
| Design Desk (capped at 4) | $60 | Knit-along plus a review of the member's own design | 2 | $120 |
| Total | 80 | $880 |
Read the two right-hand columns together: Pattern Club earns the biggest share of the $880, while Supporter holds the biggest crowd. A ladder built from the anchor should look like that. Why the top tier is capped, and how to pick the number, is in limited-seat membership tiers.
What the platform does to $880
| Platform | Rate from its pricing page | Kept per month on $880 |
|---|---|---|
| Patreon | 10% plus processing | $88.00 |
| Ko-fi Free | 5% on memberships | $44.00 |
| Memberful | $49 a month plus 4.9% | $92.12 |
| Skool Hobby | $9 a month plus 10% | $97.00 |
| Skool Pro | $99 a month plus 2.9% | $124.52 |
| Vibe | 0%; Build plan from 50 supporters | $25.00 |
Card processing is left out of every row. On Vibe the 80 members put the community in the Build band, and the month is over $500, so that month's $25 plan applies; a month under $500 would cost $0. Ko-fi's Gold plan removes its 5% for a fixed monthly cost not stated on the page we read. Whether a share or a flat plan suits you depends on your totals, which is the argument in flat fee vs revenue share; the calculator runs your own numbers.
Testing and raising a price
On Vibe memberships renew monthly and reminders go out 7, 3 and 1 days before each renewal, so a member always knows a charge is coming. Whether to offer a yearly price at all is its own question: annual vs monthly membership pricing.
Changing prices every few weeks makes members wait for the next change. Pick, hold for 60 days, then move once.
Questions
How much should I charge for a membership?
Anchor the main tier to one thing members already buy from you, such as a pattern or a class ticket, and set it so each month delivers at least that much. Put a cheaper tier below it and time-based tiers above.
Should I price by how much content I make?
No. Members pay for what the month does for them. Your time only sets the price of tiers that include personal attention, such as reviews or small live rooms.
How long should I test a membership price?
About 60 days, which covers two renewal cycles. Judge the whole window, not a single week.
Does Vibe take a share of membership payments?
No. Vibe keeps 0%. Payments are charged on your own Stripe account, and the plan is sized by supporter count, costing $0 in any month supporters pay you under $500.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Ko-fi Gold and fees checked 2026-09-23
- Memberful pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Skool pricing checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-28