Vibe

Cette page n’est pas encore traduite. Elle est affichée en anglais.

Moving from Circle: a week-by-week plan

Circle's pricing page lists Professional at $89 a month with a 2% transaction fee, Business at $199 with 1%, and Circle Plus at custom pricing with 0.5%. Check your account's export options for the member list before anything else; once that file is in hand, the data side of leaving is the easy part. What is not easy is collapsing a community built as twenty spaces into a room built as one wall. This guide follows a tabletop game master whose paid Circle community runs weekly campaigns, and it takes five weeks.

The short answer

Short answer: Export your members (check your account's export options), decide which of your spaces were really tiers and which were just folders, rebuild as up to four tiers on one wall, announce once, and run both for five weeks. You trade $89 plus 2% for a flat Vibe plan and 0% taken.

Circle organises a community into spaces, and a creator who has been there a year usually has more spaces than they meant to have. A Vibe organises a community into tiers on a single wall, with live sessions for members and direct messages where a tier includes them. The move is mostly the work of deciding what those spaces were for.

Spaces to tiers

The game master's Circle has 12 spaces for 190 paying members at $12 a month: announcements, three campaign spaces, a rules-questions space, a homebrew space, a map-sharing space, a spectator space for people who watch sessions but do not play, an events space, two archived campaign spaces, and one nobody remembers making. Sorted honestly, they are three kinds of thing.

Twelve spaces on Circle

  • Folders: announcements, rules, homebrew, maps, events
  • Access levels: three live campaign tables, spectators
  • Dead weight: two archives and the mystery space

Three tiers on one wall

  • $12 Spectator: the wall, session replays, maps and homebrew files
  • $30 Player, capped at 18 seats: three live campaign sessions a week with chat beside the table and DMs to the GM
  • $60 Table Patron, capped at 6: a private monthly one-shot session, tickets to guest one-shots

Folders become posts on the wall, filed by what they are. Access levels become tiers. Dead weight is left behind. Circle sells spaces by plan; the point of the move is not to need them.

The five-week plan

  1. Week 1: export and lay the tablePull the member list; check your account's export options for what is offered and which fields come with it. Open the Vibe, connect Stripe, create the three tiers above. Upload the map library, the homebrew rules and the last month of session replays as members-only files and video. Schedule week two's campaign sessions in the new room so they appear on the page.
  2. Week 2: players firstMessage the 18 active players directly. They are the campaign; if they move, the spectators follow. Run the week's three sessions in the new room with chat beside the table. Post a public announcement in Circle's announcement space and email the export from the new room: same price, new address, closing date three weeks out.
  3. Week 3: spectators and replaysPost replays on the wall for the $12 tier. Send spectators who have not moved the replay link as the reminder. Sell tickets to a guest one-shot for the following week; a ticketed session is the easiest way to show the room does something Circle did not.
  4. Week 4: the one-shot, and the patron tierRun the guest one-shot as a ticketed session. Open the six-seat Table Patron tier to the players who ask for more table time. Second reminder to anyone still only on Circle, found by comparing the two CSVs.
  5. Week 5: close the CirclePost the final note in Circle with the new link, cancel Circle's paid memberships on the announced date so nobody pays twice, and close the account. Win-back emails go out under your name to anyone who lapsed.

The pillar page, Own your audience, covers the export habit that makes moves like this survivable, and platform risk for creators is the case for making the habit early.

How a player pays and what you owe

A member opens the Vibe page, picks Spectator, Player or Table Patron and pays by card. The charge is made on the game master's own Stripe account through Stripe Connect; Vibe holds nothing and takes 0%. Bitcoin over Lightning can be switched on for players who prefer it. Memberships renew monthly with reminders at 7, 3 and 1 days and a cancel link on the page. Tickets for one-off sessions are sold on their own.

190supporters put the room on Build, $25 a month from 50 supporters
500live viewer-hours a month on Build: 18 players at three sessions of three hours is 162
$0owed in any month under $500 from supporters; this room passes it every month

Build also includes 50 GB for maps, handouts and replays. Extra storage and viewer-hours exist as opt-in only and are never charged unless the creator switches them on. Every member's email exports to CSV in one click, any day.

What you lose by leaving Circle

Circle does things a Vibe does not attempt, and a creator should weigh them rather than wave at them. Spaces: if your community really needs many separate rooms, each with its own membership, one wall with four tiers is a poorer fit. Co-admins: a Vibe is run by the creator, so a community with several moderators who each own a corner loses that structure. Courses, if yours run inside Circle. How many spaces, admins and streaming hours each Circle plan includes is on its pricing page and in your own account; check there rather than trusting a summary. A Vibe's live sessions are for members inside the room with viewer-hours by plan, not a public stream. Circle's transaction fee is already small, 2% on Professional, so the move is not mainly about the share; it is about $89 to $199 a month of plan against a flat Vibe plan, and about a wall with live sessions against a network of spaces.

Verdict

Move if the spaces were mostly folders and the community is really one table. Stay if you run several distinct groups under one roof with co-admins, or if courses are part of the offer. Circle alternatives works through both cases.

The bill on both sides

Vibe$100
Circle Professional$98
Out of $100 a member pays, before card processing on both. Circle Professional's 2% is from its pricing page, fetched 2026-09-23 (see Sources); Business (1%) and Plus (0.5%) are smaller still. Monthly plans are outside the bar.

The bars are nearly equal on purpose: Circle's share is small. The difference is the plan. 190 members at $12 is $2,280 a month; Circle Professional costs $89 plus 2%, about $135. A Vibe of 190 supporters is on Build at $25. The saving is about $110 a month, and it stays roughly there until the room passes 200 supporters and moves to Grow at $125, at which point the two are close again until Circle's plan would need to step up. Put your own count in the calculator; for a Circle community the answer depends more on size bands than on the percentage.

Questions

Can I export my Circle members?

The Circle pricing page we read gives plan prices and fees, not export details, so check your account's export options. You want email and which paid membership each person holds.

How do I turn Circle spaces into Vibe tiers?

Sort spaces into folders, access levels and dead weight. Folders become posts on the wall, access levels become up to four tiers, and dead weight stays behind.

Is Circle's fee the reason to move?

Not really; it is 2%, 1% or 0.5% by plan. The difference is the monthly plan ($89, $199 or custom) against a Vibe plan sized by supporters, plus what each room does.

Can I run live sessions for members on a Vibe?

Yes. Live sessions happen inside the Vibe for its members, with chat beside the work and a goal the room can see, and each plan includes a number of viewer-hours. There is no public livestream directory.

Keep the whole payment.

Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.

Sources

  1. Circle pricing checked 2026-09-23

Last updated 2026-09-24