The short answer
Short answer: Keep physical merch on Fourthwall, where it carries no percentage, and move the membership: collect your members' emails, open a Vibe with matching tiers, announce the move once with a closing date, run both for about four weeks, then close the Fourthwall membership so nobody pays twice. The membership then costs 0% of what members pay instead of Fourthwall's 5%.
Fourthwall's fees are from its pricing page (see Sources). That page says nothing about exporting members, so this guide does not describe Fourthwall's export tools; check what your own dashboard offers before you set any date.
Decide what moves and what stays
Before any announcement, split the business in two. The painter sells prints and shirts, and those stay: Fourthwall deducts the product cost from each physical sale and takes no percentage on top, and it connects to YouTube Merch Shelf, Instagram and Facebook Shopping and TikTok Shopping. Rebuilding that elsewhere buys nothing.
Stays on Fourthwall
- Prints, shirts and other physical goods
- The shopping integrations that feed the store
- Any product whose margin you are happy with
Moves to the Vibe
- The monthly membership and its members-only video
- Paint guides and tutorials sold as files
- Live painting sessions for members
The shop link goes on the Vibe's wall as a public post, so members still find the merch.
The moving steps
- Get a way to reach every memberUse whatever export your Fourthwall account gives you. If emails do not come out, post a short form to members before announcing anything, and offer something for filling it in, such as a free painting guide.
- Open the Vibe quietlySign up with an email, put a card on file (never charged; it keeps bot farms and banned accounts out), connect Stripe and open the room. There is no identity check and no fee to start.
- Rebuild the membership as tiersUp to four tiers, each with its own price and inclusions. Upload your own originals of every members-only video, and your guides as files on the wall.
- Announce once, with a datePost on Fourthwall, email your list, and pin it. Say when the old membership closes, what stays the same, and what improves.
- OverlapRun both for about four weeks. New content lands on the Vibe; Fourthwall gets a short post pointing to it.
- Close the old membershipOn the stated date, end the Fourthwall membership tiers so no one is charged twice. The store keeps running.
From one Fourthwall membership to three tiers
| On Fourthwall | On the Vibe |
|---|---|
| One $9 membership with members-only video | $9 Hobbyist tier: the wall, every tutorial video, the monthly live paint session |
| Paint guides sold as digital products | Guides as files on the wall, sold on their own or included in a tier |
| Nothing for the most committed members | $25 Workbench tier, capped at 15 seats: a small live critique of members' own miniatures each month, plus direct messages |
| Occasional livestream | A ticket for a one-off masterclass, such as wet blending or freehand banners |
Fourthwall's memberships include custom mobile apps and member badges. If your members use either, tell them in the announcement exactly how they will reach the Vibe instead: one link to its page, where they pick the tier that matches what they had.
The weeks, one by one
From then on the Vibe sends the routine mail under the painter's name: a welcome note, renewal reminders at 7, 3 and 1 days, and win-back notes for lapsed members. Every video a member receives carries an invisible mark unique to their account, so a tutorial that leaks can be traced.
What the move changes in money
140 members at $9 is $1,260 a month. On Fourthwall's free plan the membership fee is $63 of that, plus US card processing of 2.9% + 30 cents per payment. On the Vibe, 140 supporters sit in Build at $25 a month, and 0% is taken; in any month the supporters pay under $500, the plan is $0. Members pick a tier and pay by card on the painter's own Stripe account, paid straight to the painter, and anyone who prefers can pay in bitcoin over Lightning. The saving here is real but modest, about $38 a month before processing, so the better room matters as much as the fee. The fee rules themselves are laid out on what Fourthwall charges, and your own counts go in the earnings calculator.
When to leave everything on Fourthwall
Stay put if the membership is a small extra for people who already buy your merch, if members rely on a custom app, or if your tiers are cheap and numerous enough that 5% is less than a flat plan. Move the membership when it is your main income and you want tiers, capped seats and live sessions built around it.
Running two platforms has a cost in attention, and a creator with 30 members at $5 would pay Fourthwall $7.50 a month in membership fees. That is not worth a move. The wider case for keeping your member list in your own hands is on Own your audience, the options beyond Vibe are on Fourthwall alternatives, and the direct comparison is Vibe vs Fourthwall.
Questions
Can I keep my Fourthwall store and use Vibe for memberships?
Yes. Keep the store running on Fourthwall, where physical products carry no percentage, and link it from a public post on the Vibe's wall so members still find it.
Can I export my members from Fourthwall?
The pricing page we read does not say. Check your Fourthwall dashboard, and if emails do not come out, collect them with a form before you announce.
How long should both memberships run?
About four weeks. Long enough for members who check in monthly to see the news, short enough that nobody pays on both.
What does a Vibe of 140 members cost?
Build, $25 a month, and only in months when supporters pay you $500 or more. Vibe takes 0% of the payments.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Fourthwall pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Fourthwall pricing (Pro plan and features) checked 2026-09-24
Last updated 2026-09-27