Vibe

Cette page n’est pas encore traduite. Elle est affichée en anglais.

Moving from Gumroad: a week-by-week plan

Gumroad is a shop that also does memberships, and the move away from it is really two moves: the buyers and the subscribers. Its pricing page states 10% plus $0.50 on every direct sale and 30% on sales through its Discover marketplace, with no monthly fee. This plan takes six weeks because products need re-listing as well as members need re-joining, and it follows a photographer who sells preset packs and runs a monthly editing membership.

The short answer

Short answer: Split what you have on Gumroad into products and members, move the membership first with matching prices, re-list the products as priced posts on the new wall, and run both for six weeks so every subscriber sees at least one renewal reminder. Gumroad's fee is 10% plus $0.50 per direct sale, per its pricing page; a Vibe takes 0%.

The photographer in this example has sold 4,300 preset packs on Gumroad over four years and has 260 members at $9 a month who get a new pack monthly plus feedback on their edits. The packs are a product business. The members are a community. They move at different speeds and for different reasons, and the plan below keeps them apart.

10% + $0.50per direct sale on Gumroad, from its pricing page
30%on sales through Gumroad Discover
0%of what members pay, on a Vibe

Products and members are different problems

The product side

  • Buyers paid once and may never return
  • Gumroad Discover brings new buyers you did not find yourself, at 30%
  • Gumroad runs the checkout on those sales; check its pricing page for what it handles on tax

The member side

  • Members pay monthly and expect a place, not a download
  • They are the people who will show up to a live edit session
  • They are the reason a community platform is worth running

The honest question is whether to move the products at all. A pack that sells mostly through Discover is paying 30% for a customer you would not otherwise have; keeping it there can be rational. A pack that sells through your own links is paying 10% plus $0.50 for a checkout page, and that one can move. Check your account's export options for both lists, buyers and subscribers, before deciding; the subscriber list is the one the plan depends on.

The six-week plan

  1. Week 1: open the room, members onlyOpen the Vibe, connect Stripe, and set a $9 tier that mirrors the Gumroad membership: monthly pack as a members-only file, plus a wall where members post edits for feedback. Add a $30 tier capped at ten seats for a monthly live edit session where the photographer works on members' RAW files with chat beside the screen. Upload the last three monthly packs so the room has weight.
  2. Week 2: tell subscribersEmail the exported subscriber list from the new room and post to members on Gumroad. Same price, new place, the live session as the new thing, closing date five weeks out. Ask the first ten who join to post an edit on the wall that week so the feedback loop is visible to the next arrivals.
  3. Week 3: first live editRun the session. Post the replay for the $9 tier as well; this is the month to be generous. Send the replay to subscribers who have not moved, found by comparing the two lists.
  4. Week 4: re-list the products that should movePut the preset packs that sell through your own links on the wall as posts sold on their own, each with its price. Leave the Discover-driven packs on Gumroad. Email past buyers once, from the new room, with the new links; do not chase them after that.
  5. Week 5: second reminder, both placesPublish the monthly pack in both rooms. The reminder to unmoved subscribers says this is the last pack that will appear on Gumroad.
  6. Week 6: close the membershipEnd the Gumroad membership on the date given. Keep the Gumroad product page for whatever still sells through Discover. Win-back emails go out under your name to lapsed members over the following weeks.

The announcement copy lives in how to announce a platform move; the why is in Own your audience.

How members pay on the new room

A member opens the Vibe page, picks the $9 or $30 tier and pays by card. The charge is made on the photographer's own Stripe account through Stripe Connect; Vibe never holds it and never takes a share. Bitcoin over Lightning can be switched on for members who want it. Renewals are monthly, with reminders at 7, 3 and 1 days and a cancel link on the page.

Every photo and video a member receives carries an invisible mark unique to that account, on every plan, which matters to a photographer handing out preset packs and RAW files: a leaked copy identifies the account it was delivered to. And every member's email exports to CSV in one click, any day, so the next move, if there ever is one, starts from a file you already have.

  • Packs uploaded as members-only files before the announcement
  • Live edit session scheduled and visible on the page
  • Subscriber export saved outside Gumroad
  • Decided which products stay on Gumroad for Discover

What you lose by leaving Gumroad

Gumroad's pricing page describes two things that are real losses. Discover: a marketplace where, in its words, new customers find and buy from creators. A Vibe has no marketplace, so any sale that came from Discover browsing rather than your own audience is a sale you must now find another way to make. The checkout itself: Gumroad runs the sale end to end, and whatever it handles around tax on those sales (check its pricing page for the current wording) stops being handled for you. On a Vibe the charge sits on your own Stripe account, so tax on what you sell is yours to configure and file through Stripe. For a creator selling into many countries that can be real work.

Watch out

Do not move a product line that lives on Discover just to save the fee. 30% of a sale you would not have made is better than 0% of nothing. Move the membership, move the products your own audience buys, and let Discover keep the rest.

If products are most of your income and the membership is a side line, Gumroad alternatives is clear that a shop-first creator may be better staying.

The fee on the membership side

Vibe$100
Gumroad (direct)$89.50
Out of $100 paid by direct link, before processing. Gumroad's 10% plus $0.50 is from its pricing page, fetched 2026-09-23 (see Sources); the bar treats $100 as one payment. Vibe's plan fee is separate.

260 members at $9 is $2,340 a month. Gumroad's direct-sale fee on that, taken as 260 payments, is $234 plus $130 in fifty-cent charges: $364. A Vibe of 260 supporters is on Grow at $125 a month, owed because the month passes $500. The gap is roughly $240 a month before any product sales are counted, and it widens as the membership grows. Check your own figures; a membership of forty people at $5 would not see the same story.

Questions

Can I export my Gumroad subscribers and buyers?

Gumroad's pricing page does not describe exports; check your account's export options. You want two lists, subscribers with status and buyers by product, and the plan only depends on the first.

Should I move my products off Gumroad too?

Only the ones your own audience buys through your links. Products that sell through Gumroad Discover are reaching people you did not find, and the 30% there is buying that reach.

Who handles sales tax after the move?

Check Gumroad's pricing page for what it currently handles on tax for sales made there. On a Vibe the charge is on your own Stripe account, so tax on what you sell is configured and filed by you through Stripe.

What does Vibe take from a membership payment?

0%. Members pay by card on your own Stripe account. Vibe charges a flat plan by supporter count, and a month in which supporters pay you less than $500 costs $0.

Keep the whole payment.

Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.

Sources

  1. Gumroad pricing checked 2026-09-23

Last updated 2026-09-24