The short answer
Short answer: Charge a monthly membership for ongoing access, sell tickets for one-off sessions, and take the payments on an account in your own name so the money is yours from the first charge. If the group has been free, give members a month's notice, keep a free layer, and offer your longest-standing members a founding price.
Decision one: how members pay
| Billing model | Best for | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly membership | A community with a regular rhythm: weekly posts, a monthly live session | Members expect something every month; plan it |
| Tiered membership | Members who want different amounts of you | Each extra tier is one more choice to explain; keep the list short |
| Ticket per session | Workshops, critiques, special evenings | Tickets alone give you no steady base |
| Pay per item | Patterns, templates, recipe packs | Good as an extra, thin as the whole model |
The models combine well: a monthly membership as the base, tickets for occasional deeper sessions, and a few files sold on their own. On Vibe you can run all of them in one place: up to four tiers, tickets for one-off sessions, and any post or file on the wall sold on its own. Memberships renew monthly and a member can cancel from your page at any time, with reminders sent before each renewal.
Decision two: whose account the money lands in
This question is easy to skip, and it is the one that matters most if anything ever goes wrong. On many platforms, the platform is the merchant: members pay the platform, and the platform pays you later, on its schedule, after its share. On others, members pay you directly through a payment account in your name, and the platform charges you separately.
Platform as the merchant
- Money passes through the platform first
- Its share comes off the top
- Payouts follow its calendar
You as the merchant
- Charges land on your own account
- The platform bills you for its plan instead
- Payouts follow your payment provider's schedule
Vibe works the second way. Card payments are charged on your own Stripe account, so Vibe never holds the money and never takes a share of it; Stripe pays out to your bank on Stripe's schedule. You can also accept bitcoin over Lightning, paid to your own wallet, for supporters who prefer it or who live where Stripe does not operate. The deeper explanation is in getting paid as a creator.
Decision three: the price, and what the platform takes from it
Price the tier most people will choose at a level a keen regular pays without discussing it at home, then set a cheaper tier below it and a capped, pricier one above. How to price a membership goes step by step. Then check what reaches you. Card processing applies almost everywhere; on top of it, platforms charge a share, a plan or both.
| Platform | What it charges, from its pricing page |
|---|---|
| Patreon | 10% of earnings, plus processing, conversion and payout fees |
| Circle | Professional $89 a month + 2%, Business $199 + 1%, Scale $419 + 1%, billed annually; Circle Plus custom + 0.5% |
| Kajabi | From $179 a month ($143 billed yearly), no share; 2.9% + $0.30 processing on Basic with Kajabi Payments |
| Podia | Mover $42 a month + 5%; Shaker $84 with no transaction fee; 2.9% + 30 cents processing |
| Vibe | 0% of member payments; a flat plan by community size, $0 in any month under $500 from supporters |
The conversation: turning a free group paid
If your community has been free, the switch is where most of the risk is. People do not mind paying; they mind being surprised. A plan that works:
Do not move old free posts behind the paywall. Members who helped build the archive will take it personally. Charge for what comes next.
After the switch, a welcome email to each new member, renewal reminders and a win-back note for anyone who lapses do much of the keeping. On Vibe they are automatic and go out under your name. The whole launch path is in starting a paid community, and the ways to earn beyond membership are in how to monetize a community.
Questions
Should I charge monthly or per event?
Monthly for the base, because it gives you a predictable month, and per event for the occasional deeper session. The two sit side by side without competing.
How do members pay on Vibe?
A supporter opens your Vibe page, picks a tier and pays by card, charged on your own Stripe account. There are no set-up steps on their side.
What does Circle charge for a paid community?
Circle's pricing page shows Professional at $89 a month with a 2% transaction fee, Business at $199 with 1%, and Scale at $419 with 1%, all billed annually, plus a custom Circle Plus plan at 0.5%.
How do I start charging a group that used to be free?
Give a month's notice with the reason and date, keep a free layer, offer early members a founding price, and charge only for new material rather than locking old posts.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Circle pricing (annual billing, with Scale) checked 2026-09-24
- Kajabi pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Podia pricing checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-28