The short answer
Short answer: Decide what sits behind the paywall, choose one of three builds (an add-on to your own website, an all-in-one course platform, or a hosted community), connect a payment account, set your tiers and launch to the audience you already have. For a craft community, a hosted platform is the fastest route; on Vibe it costs nothing until your supporters pay you $500 in a month.
The three ways to build it
1. An add-on to your own website
You keep your site and add a membership layer that handles sign-up, billing and locked pages. Memberful is the clearest verified example: $49 a month plus a 4.9% transaction fee, a Stripe account required, and integrations with WordPress, Mailchimp, Discord and Kit. This suits a creator whose website already gets the traffic and who is comfortable maintaining it.
2. An all-in-one course platform
These give you a website builder, a course area, email and checkout in one account. Kajabi runs from $179 a month ($143 billed yearly) with no revenue share. Podia runs from $42 a month with a 5% fee, or $84 with none. Teachable runs from $39 a month with a 7.5% fee, or $89 with none. They suit a creator whose main product is a structured course.
3. A hosted community
Members join a space you run: a feed of posts, live sessions, tiers and messages. Circle, Skool, Mighty Networks and Vibe work this way. It suits a creator whose members want to take part, not just consume: people who knit, cook, build or shoot often want to show their own work and ask questions.
| Route | Example and cost, from its pricing page | You maintain | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Own site add-on | Memberful: $49 a month + 4.9% | The website, hosting and plugins | Writers and publishers with an existing site |
| Course platform | Kajabi from $179; Podia from $42 + 5%; Teachable from $39 + 7.5% | Course structure and pages | One flagship course |
| Hosted community | Circle $89 + 2%, $199 + 1% or $419 + 1% a month, billed annually; Skool $9 + 10% or $99 + 2.9% | Posts and sessions | Members who take part |
| Hosted community | Vibe: 0% taken; $0 in any month under $500 from supporters, then from $25 | Posts and sessions | A craft community with tiers and live sessions |
The seven steps
- Write down what is behind the wallList four things a member gets that a follower does not. If you cannot fill four lines, start with a single tier.
- Pick the buildUse the table above. If you have no website worth keeping, skip route one.
- Connect payments you ownMemberful, for one, requires a Stripe account. On Vibe, supporters pay by card on your own Stripe account, and Vibe never holds the money. You can also accept bitcoin over Lightning.
- Set up to four tiersEach with a price and a list of inclusions. Cap one if it depends on your time. Membership tiers and pricing has worked examples.
- Fill the first month before launchSchedule four posts and one live session so the first members arrive to something. A scheduler for posts and sessions is built into Vibe.
- Set the automatic emailsA welcome note, renewal reminders and a win-back message. On Vibe these go out under your name, with reminders at 7, 3 and 1 days before a renewal.
- Launch to the people who already follow youNot to strangers. Your first 50 paying members covers who to ask and what to say.
Opening one on Vibe, concretely
If the hosted route fits, here is what opening a Vibe takes. Sign up with an email. Put a card on file; it is never charged, and exists so that bot farms cannot open accounts by the hundred and so that someone removed for prohibited content stays out. Vibe keeps a fingerprint of the card, never the number. Connect Stripe, a Lightning wallet, or both. Then name your tiers, post something, and share the link.
From there, a supporter opens your Vibe page, picks a tier and pays by card. There are no set-up steps on their side. Memberships renew monthly, and a member can cancel from your page whenever they like.
Mistakes that sink a new membership site
The most expensive mistake is not the platform fee. It is building for months before a single person has paid.
- Building the site before the audience. A beautiful site with no one invited is a cost with no return. Launch small and improve it with members inside.
- Choosing a platform you cannot leave. Check that you can export every member's email before you launch. On Vibe it is one click to CSV, any day.
- Ignoring the fee model. A percentage that feels small at 20 members is a large bill at 500. Compare a share against a flat plan in flat fee vs revenue share.
- No live element. For a craft, a live session is often the one thing followers cannot get free. Build the tiers around it.
The longer version of the whole journey, with a worked example, is in how to start a paid community.
Questions
Do I need my own website to start a membership site?
No. An add-on like Memberful needs one; course platforms and hosted communities give you a page to share. On Vibe, your Vibe page is where supporters pick a tier and pay.
How much does it cost to start a membership site?
It depends on the route. Memberful is $49 a month plus 4.9%; Kajabi starts at $179 a month; Circle's plans are $89, $199 and $419 a month, billed annually, plus a 2% or 1% transaction fee. Vibe costs nothing to open and $0 in any month your supporters pay you under $500.
Can I move my members later?
Only if you can export them. Confirm the export before launch. On Vibe every member's email exports to CSV in one click.
How many tiers should a new membership site have?
Start with one or two. Vibe allows up to four, and a tier can be capped, so add the premium tier once members ask for more of your time.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Memberful pricing (plan and fee) checked 2026-09-23
- Memberful pricing (features) checked 2026-09-24
- Kajabi pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Podia pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Teachable pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Circle pricing (annual billing) checked 2026-09-24
- Skool pricing checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-28