The short answer
Short answer: Keep the Stripe account you already use with Memberful, connect it to the new room, rebuild your plans as tiers at the same prices, announce once, and run both for four weeks before cancelling Memberful. You go from $49 plus 4.9% to a flat Vibe plan and 0% taken.
Most platform moves involve a new payment setup on the creator's side. Memberful is different: its pricing page says a Stripe account is required, so you already have one, already verified, with payouts already landing in your bank. A Vibe also charges members on the creator's own Stripe account. The account carries over; only the subscriptions inside it need recreating, and that is what the four weeks are for.
What the Stripe head start gives you
Check your account's export options for the member list with plan names; Memberful's pricing page does not describe exports, so this page will not either. The Stripe dashboard is a second place to confirm who is active, because every subscription Memberful created lives there.
The four-week plan
The music teacher has 210 members: 170 on a $12 library plan with every lesson video and backing track, and 40 on a $35 plan that adds a weekly live practice session and a monthly one-to-one slot. She has been paying Memberful $49 a month plus 4.9% of about $3,440, roughly $217 a month all in.
- Week 1: connect and rebuildOpen the Vibe, put a card on file (never charged), connect the existing Stripe account. Create a $12 tier with the wall and the lesson library uploaded as members-only video and files, and a $35 tier capped at forty seats with the live session and direct messages included. Schedule the first live practice session for week two so the page shows a date.
- Week 2: announce, then playEmail every member from the new room and post the same note inside Memberful. Same prices, same library, the practice session now has chat beside the music and a goal the room can see. Run the first session that week for whoever has moved; post the replay for the rest.
- Week 3: reminders by planCompare the Memberful export with the Vibe CSV. Write to the $35 members individually; there are forty of them and they are most of the income. Send one batched reminder to the $12 members with the newest lesson as the hook.
- Week 4: cancel MemberfulCancel the remaining Memberful subscriptions on the announced date so nobody is charged twice, then close the Memberful account. Vibe's win-back emails follow anyone who lapsed, under your name.
Plans to tiers
| Memberful plan | Vibe tier | Included |
|---|---|---|
| $12 Library | $12 Library | Wall, lesson videos, backing tracks as files, renewal reminders at 7, 3 and 1 days |
| $35 Practice | $35 Practice, capped at 40 | Everything above, weekly live session, direct messages, one-to-one slot booked by DM |
A member pays by picking a tier and entering a card; the charge is a direct charge on your Stripe account and Vibe takes none of it. You can also accept bitcoin over Lightning for members who prefer it. Every member's email exports to CSV in one click, any day. Annual plans are not something this page can promise, so if your Memberful members are on annual billing, plan the move to land after their renewal and tell them the new room renews monthly; the long argument for keeping the list in your own hands is in Own your audience.
What you lose by leaving Memberful
Memberful is a different kind of tool from a Vibe, and a creator whose setup depends on that difference should weigh it carefully. Memberful is a membership layer: it sits on top of a site, a newsletter or a feed you already run and puts a paywall and a checkout in front of them. If your paywall lives on your own website and your writing lives in a newsletter tool, Memberful is the glue between them, and a Vibe is a separate room, not glue. Which integrations, billing intervals and checkout options Memberful currently offers is on its pricing page and in your own dashboard; check there before counting anything as lost. A Vibe is one place with a wall, tiers, live sessions and emails; it is not something you bolt onto a site you already run.
Memberful does, Vibe does not
- Paywall a site or a feed you already run
- Plug into the tools your site and newsletter already use
- Whatever billing and checkout options your Memberful plan includes today
- Annual billing, if your plan offers it; a Vibe renews monthly
Vibe does, Memberful does not
- The room itself: wall, live sessions with chat, tickets, DMs
- 0% taken and no $49 base fee
- An invisible mark on every photo and video a member receives
- $0 in any month under $500 from supporters
If the site and the newsletter are the product and the membership is a paywall on them, stay; Memberful alternatives says so and explains when.
The cost, side by side
For the music teacher: Memberful costs $49 plus 4.9% of $3,440, about $217 a month. A Vibe of 210 supporters is on Grow at $125 a month, owed because supporters pay well over $500. The saving is about $92 a month at this size. At 500 members the Memberful share alone would pass $400 while the Vibe plan would still be Grow until 1,000 supporters. Run your own numbers; and if you are under 50 members, the Vibe plan is Free and the comparison is $49 plus 4.9% against $0.
Questions
Do I need a new Stripe account to leave Memberful?
No. Memberful's pricing page says a Stripe account is required, and a Vibe charges members on the creator's own Stripe account. Connect the one you already have.
Will members be charged twice during the move?
Only if you leave both subscriptions running. Cancel each member's Memberful subscription once they have joined the new room, and cancel the rest on the announced closing date.
Can I export my Memberful members?
Memberful's pricing page does not describe exports; check your account's export options. Your Stripe dashboard also lists every active subscription Memberful created.
What happens to members on annual Memberful plans?
Time the move so it lands after their renewal date, and tell them the new room renews monthly. Do not cancel an annual subscription mid-term without refunding the remainder.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Memberful pricing checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-24