In two sentences
Short answer: On membership income, Fourthwall keeps half what Patreon does: a 5% flat fee on its free plan against Patreon's 10% of earnings. Fourthwall is a storefront with memberships built in, and Patreon is a membership platform first, so the better fit depends on whether your supporters mostly subscribe or mostly shop.
Fee by type of sale
| What is sold | Patreon | Fourthwall |
|---|---|---|
| Membership | 10% of income earned | 5% flat fee |
| Digital product | 10%, as income earned on Patreon (one-time payments are listed) | 5% on the free plan, no fee on Pro |
| Physical product | Not described on the pricing page | No percentage; product costs are deducted instead |
| Card processing | Charged on top; rate not on the page we could read | 2.9% + 30 cents on US card transactions |
| Plan | None, free to start | Free, or Pro at $15 a month or $180 a year |
| Other items named | Currency conversion, payout fees, applicable taxes | Pro adds unlimited team members, 100 GB of digital product storage, a free .store domain, priority 24/7 support and $120 a year of shop credit |
The cells come from patreon.com/pricing and fourthwall.com/pricing on the dates listed under Sources. A cell that says a rate was not on the page means exactly that; it does not mean the charge is zero.
One month, three kinds of income
Picture a creator whose month brings $1,200 in memberships and $300 in digital downloads, plus a small merch drop. Here is what each platform takes before card processing.
| Patreon | Fourthwall free plan | Fourthwall Pro | |
|---|---|---|---|
| $1,200 memberships | $120 | $60 | $60 |
| $300 digital downloads | $30 | $15 | $0 |
| Plan fee | $0 | $0 | $15 |
| Total before processing | $150 | $75 | $75 |
| Merch drop | Not on the pricing page | Product costs deducted, no percentage | Product costs deducted, no percentage |
On this month, Fourthwall takes half of what Patreon does, and the free plan and Pro land on the same total. That is not a coincidence: $300 of digital sales is exactly where Pro's $15 equals the 5% it removes.
Fourthwall Pro pays for itself on fees once digital product sales pass $300 a month. Below that, take it for the team members, storage, domain or shop credit, or leave it off. It does not change the 5% on memberships.
Where each one meets its audience
Patreon lists
- Monthly and annual subscriptions across several tiers
- Free trials, discounts and sales
- Hosting for audio, images, text, video and livestreaming
- Newsletters, chats, DMs and comments
- Member analytics and podcast tools
Fourthwall lists
- Memberships with video and image hosting and monthly charging
- Custom mobile apps and member badges
- YouTube Merch Shelf integration
- Instagram, Facebook and TikTok Shopping
- Physical products sold at product cost
Fourthwall's list leans outward, toward the feeds where fans already scroll: products appear on YouTube, Instagram, Facebook and TikTok. Patreon's leans inward, toward the membership itself, with tiers, trials, chats and a podcast feed. A creator with a large social audience and a merch line reads the right-hand column as a plan. A creator with a smaller, closer audience reads the left.
When Patreon is the better choice
Patreon earns its extra five points when the membership is the whole business and needs more than a monthly charge. Annual billing, several tiers with different perks, one-time payments, trials and sales, newsletters, chats and DMs, analytics and podcast tools are all on its pricing page. A podcaster or video creator who wants every part of the relationship in one place, with no shop to stock, gets tools they will use every week. For the full list of what sits on top of Patreon's percentage, read Patreon fees.
When Fourthwall is the better choice
Patreon if the membership is the product and you want the deepest set of membership tools. Fourthwall if you sell merch and downloads, want a membership beside them, and would rather give up 5% of membership income than 10%.
Fourthwall is the better choice for a creator with a shop. Physical products carry no percentage, memberships cost half Patreon's rate, and the storefront plugs into the social platforms where fans already shop. A creator with $3,000 a month in memberships keeps $150 more on Fourthwall than on Patreon, before processing. The rest of the field is on Fourthwall alternatives.
For a membership without a storefront
A creator whose community is built around a craft, with live sessions and a wall of work rather than a shop, has a third pricing model to weigh. Vibe takes 0% of what supporters pay and charges a flat plan sized by how many supporters the Vibe holds: $0 up to 49, then $25, $125, $325 or $999 a month, and $0 for any month in which supporters pay you less than $500. There is no merch shop; a post, video or file on the wall can be sold on its own.
Vibe vs Fourthwall goes through that comparison in full.
Questions
Does Fourthwall take less than Patreon on memberships?
Yes. Fourthwall's pricing page states a 5% flat fee on memberships on its free plan; Patreon's states 10% of the income you earn. Processing is charged on top on both.
Is Fourthwall Pro worth $15 a month?
On fees alone, once your digital product sales pass $300 a month, because Pro removes the 5% fee on them. Pro also adds unlimited team members, 100 GB of digital storage, a free .store domain, priority support and $120 a year of shop credit.
Does Fourthwall take a percentage of merch?
No percentage on physical products, per its pricing page. Product costs are deducted from the sale instead.
Does Patreon sell merch?
Patreon's pricing page does not describe merch or physical products, so this page makes no claim either way.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Fourthwall pricing (fees, processing, Pro price) checked 2026-09-23
- Fourthwall pricing (Pro benefits, membership features, integrations) checked 2026-09-24
Last updated 2026-09-26