The short answer
Short answer: You own your members' email addresses and the relationship behind them; everything else on a platform is rented. To move, get every email out first, announce the move with a date and a reason, open the new place at the same prices or better, run both for a month, and only then close the old one.
Followers, subscribers and patrons are not the same as a list. A follower is an entry in someone else's database that you can reach only while that database lets you. An email address in a file on your own computer is yours, on any platform and on none. Every step below is about turning the first into the second before you need it.
What you own, and what you rent
Rented from the platform
- Your follower count and your profile URL
- The payment relationship, when the platform is the merchant
- Your posts, if there is no export
- The algorithm's willingness to show you
Yours wherever you go
- Every email address you have in a file
- Your name, your craft, and the habit people have of showing up for you
- The originals of your work
- The prices you set and the promises you made
Platforms differ in how much of the left column they let you carry over. Some publish an export policy plainly: Buy Me a Coffee's homepage states creators have 100% ownership of their supporters, that it never emails them, and that the list can be exported any time. Substack says it is free to leave. Others do not say on the pages we could read, and this guide does not guess for them; it gives you the steps that work whether or not an export button exists. The reasons a platform can become a liability overnight are collected in platform risk for creators.
Step one: get every email out
Do this before you announce anything, and do it even if you are not moving. A list you exported last week is worth more than any feature.
- Look for an export in the platform's settingsCheck the members or patrons page in your account for a download or export option, usually a CSV. If yours has one, download it now and again the day before you close.
- If there is no export, ask your members directlyPost a members-only note with a short form or a reply address: "I keep a list of my own so I can always reach you; add your email here." Members who pay you will do it. Give it two weeks and post it twice.
- Check the fileOpen the CSV. You want at least an email per row, and ideally the tier and the join date so you can welcome long-standing members by name.
- Keep it somewhere that is not the platformYour own computer and one backup. This file is the asset.
The mechanics per platform, including what the export contains where it exists, are in exporting your member list. On Vibe the same job is one click: every member's email exports to CSV at any time, so the day you decide to leave is no different from any other day.
Step two: open the new place before you tell anyone
Nobody should click your announcement and find an empty room. Set the new community up completely first.
- Same tier names and the same prices, or slightly better. A move is not the moment to raise prices; the goodwill is worth more than the margin.
- The best of your archive already on the wall, members-only, so the first arrivals find the things they joined you for.
- A welcome email that goes out under your name the moment someone joins. On Vibe that is automatic.
- The first live session already scheduled, a week or two after the announcement, so there is a reason to move now rather than later.
Give long-standing members a private reason to move first: a capped tier held open for them for two weeks, or a session only they are invited to. Your most loyal people become the ones who tell everyone else it is fine over there.
Step three: announce it once, plainly
The announcement that works has four parts and no apology: what is changing, why, the date, and the one link. The reason can be the fee, the features, or simply that you want to own the room; members respect any honest reason and distrust a vague one.
Send it three ways on the same day: a post on the old platform, an email to the list you exported, and a public post wherever you are found. Then repeat it once a week until the close date, each time with a short update: how many have moved, what has happened in the new room, what is coming. The full template, with wording for the fee-based and feature-based versions, is in how to announce you are leaving.
Do not badmouth the old platform in the announcement. Some of your members like it, some found you through it, and it makes the move about the platform rather than about your work.
Step four: run both for a month, then close
Some members will not follow, and that is normal. A member who was staying out of habit stops paying when the habit breaks. The ones who move are the ones who were paying for you, and they are the community you wanted. The platform-specific week-by-week plans, starting with moving from Patreon, go through the differences.
How a Vibe keeps you in control after the move
The point of moving is not to trade one landlord for another. A Vibe is built so that leaving it would be as easy as leaving the last place, which is the only honest way to ask you to come.
- Every member's email exports to CSV in one click, any day. If you leave, you leave with your people.
- Payments are charged on your own Stripe account, so the payment relationship is between you and your member. Vibe never holds the money and takes 0% of it. You can also accept bitcoin over Lightning.
- The emails your members get (welcome, renewal reminders at 7, 3 and 1 days, win-back, premiere announcements) go out under your name, not Vibe's.
- Up to four tiers with their own prices, a wall, live sessions for members, tickets, direct messages where the tier includes them.
- A flat plan sized by how many supporters you hold, and $0 owed in any month they pay you less than $500.
If the fee is what is pushing you to move, the arithmetic is on the Patreon alternative page and you can check your own numbers on the calculator.
Questions
Can I export my patrons from Patreon?
This page did not verify Patreon's export options. Check the members or patrons page in your own account for a download; if there is none, use the direct-ask method above to collect emails from your members before you announce a move.
How long should I run both platforms?
About a month. Announce on day zero, hold the first live session in the new room in week two, email the unmoved once in week three, export the old list a final time and close in week four.
Will I lose members in a move?
Some, usually the ones who were paying out of habit. The members who follow you are the ones who were paying for your work, and a win-back email after the move recovers a share of the rest.
Can I export my members from Vibe?
Yes. Every member's email exports to CSV in one click, on any day, on every plan.
Should I raise prices when I move?
No. Keep the same tiers and prices, or make them slightly better. The move asks for trust; a price rise at the same time spends it.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Buy Me a Coffee homepage checked 2026-09-23
- Substack about checked 2026-09-23
Last updated 2026-09-23