The short answer
Short answer: Move the paid part to a platform built around posts, files, tiers and live sessions, and keep Discord only as a free chat if your members like it. Circle, Skool, Mighty Networks and Vibe all do this; Vibe takes 0% of what members pay and costs nothing until they pay you $500 in a month.
Why the paid part outgrows a chat server
Nothing is wrong with Discord for talking. The friction shows up in three places once money is involved.
Things get buried
A chat server is organised by time. A pattern, a recording or a detailed answer posted three weeks ago is hard for a new member to find, and new members are the ones deciding whether to renew.
The work has no home
Craft communities run on things: files, photos of members' progress, long videos. A wall where each post can be public, members-only or sold on its own gives that work a place that chat channels do not.
The relationship lives inside someone else's app
Members on a chat server are accounts on that app. Whether you can reach them by email if you move depends on how you set up payments and sign-up. Before you choose any setup, confirm you will hold a list of your paying members' emails.
Discord's own paid features and fees were not verified for this page, so this guide does not quote them. If you are weighing them, read Discord's current terms directly. A full comparison is on Discord alternatives and Vibe vs Discord.
Three ways to set it up
- Discord plus a membership toolMembers pay through a separate tool that grants access to private channels. Memberful, for example, lists an integration with Discord on its Standard plan, at $49 a month plus a 4.9% transaction fee. Conversation stays in Discord; payments and the member list live in the tool.
- A hybridKeep a free Discord for chat and banter, and run the paid community on a separate platform with the files, sessions and tiers. The free server becomes the front door; the paid room is where the work happens.
- No Discord at allEverything moves to one community platform: posts, files, live sessions, direct messages and the member list. Fewer places for members to check, and one set of settings for you.
If your members love the chat, the hybrid is the gentlest move. You do not have to take away what works to add what is missing.
Where to run it: platforms and their fees
| Platform | What it charges, from its pricing page | Live sessions |
|---|---|---|
| Circle | Professional $89 a month + 2%, Business $199 + 1%, Scale $419 + 1%, billed annually; Circle Plus custom + 0.5% | Live events on every plan |
| Skool | Hobby $9 a month + 10%; Pro $99 + 2.9% | Live calls on both plans |
| Mighty Networks | Launch $79 a month + 2%; Scale $179 + 1%; Growth $354 + 0.5% | Livestreams of 100, 200 or 1,000 viewers by plan |
| Patreon | 10% of earnings plus processing, conversion and payout fees | Livestreaming listed among its features |
| Vibe | 0%; $0 in any month under $500 from supporters, then $25 to $999 by community size | Inside your Vibe for its members, with chat beside the work |
Moving a paid Discord community
If paid members are already in Discord, move them with the same care you would give any platform change. Announce the date and the reason. Open the new tiers at the same prices, or slightly better for the people who have been there longest. Post the first month's material in the new place before anyone arrives. Keep the Discord open for a few weeks, with a pinned link to the new home.
On Vibe, members pick a tier on your page and pay by card on your own Stripe account, paid straight to you; you can also accept bitcoin over Lightning. A welcome email goes out under your name as each person joins, and every member's email exports to CSV any day, so the list is yours whatever you decide later. The longer playbook is in own your audience.
When Discord is still the better choice
If your community is mostly conversation, gaming sessions in voice, or a crowd that already lives in Discord all day, keep it there and add a paywall tool. If it is a craft community where members pay for files, sessions and your feedback, give the paid part its own home.
Discord is excellent at real-time talk, voice rooms and the casual hanging out that makes some communities feel alive, and members already have it open. Asking them to check a second app has a cost. Weigh it honestly: the right setup is the one your members will actually use. For the full start-to-finish path, see starting a paid community, and run the fee comparison for your own numbers on the calculator.
Questions
Can I run a paid community without Discord?
Yes. Community platforms such as Circle, Skool, Mighty Networks and Vibe hold posts, files, tiers and live sessions in one place, so a chat server becomes optional.
What does Discord take from paid memberships?
Discord's fees were not verified for this page, so we do not state a number. Check Discord's current terms directly before comparing.
Can I keep a free Discord and a paid community elsewhere?
Yes. That hybrid lets the free server handle chat, while the paid platform holds the files, sessions and member list.
Does Vibe take a share of member payments?
No. Vibe takes 0% and charges a flat plan by community size, which is $0 in any month your supporters pay you under $500.
Start on the Free plan tonight. Supporters pay your own wallet in seconds, and Vibe never takes a percentage.
Sources
- Circle pricing (annual billing, with Scale) checked 2026-09-24
- Skool pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Skool pricing (features) checked 2026-09-24
- Mighty Networks pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Mighty Networks pricing (limits) checked 2026-09-24
- Patreon pricing checked 2026-09-23
- Memberful pricing (plan and fee) checked 2026-09-23
- Memberful pricing (features) checked 2026-09-24
Last updated 2026-09-28